English | Italian

"Hastings juror speaks:..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
Defense wants to inform jury about risk of lethal injection in death penalty eligible case
Juror rates criminal defense lawyer Ryan Pacyga
Zimmerman juror calls for change in self-defense laws
Jeffrey Toobin Claims Zimmerman Juror B-37 'Sympathetic' To Defense From Beginning
Judge says jury can't see Trayvon Martin texts, photos
Presiding juror says Russell defense lacked evidence
Continue »
Pop theme

Bibeau,Europe budget,Joko Widodo,Ebola Virus,Bharatiya Janata Party,Oscar Pistorius,Dilma Rousseff,Jeffrey Fowle,Taylor Swift,Zellweger

Related theme

defense felt,car

Hastings juror speaks: 'They couldn't get past the badge'


said juror defense

2013-06-24 16:12:03

Spoke this morning with a jurorin the manslaughter trial of former LRPD officer Josh Hastings.The trial ended in a hung jury and mistrial yesterday after two full days of deliberations. The marquee quote from the juror on the two female holdouts who refused to convict: "They were biased. I really feel like they were, because they couldn't get past the badge."

In part, said the juror, the two holdouts favored acquittal because Hastings in the fatal shooting was "preventing future crimes." She said that by the time the jury realized they were hopelessly deadlocked, the ten members who favored conviction were unanimous in their belief he should be convicted of the lesser charge of Negligent Homicide.

The juror asked that we keep her name confidential. Read details from a

long conversation with her on the jump...

Also, Josh Hastings himself appears to have some comments on this Facebook page, Justice for Josh. A couple of posts are shown below, the first from late last night, the second from Saturday night.

The juror said that the holdouts in the case were two women, who seemed to be reluctant to consider that Hastings might be guilty. She said that as deliberations wore on, the conversations between the two jurors and those who favored a guilty verdict became increasingly heated. "From what I could tell, and what several others observed," the juror said, "when we tried to get them to explain to us how he was not guilty — how he could have known that firing into that car would result in the death of someone — they kept coming back to: 'Well, the car's coming at him.' We were like: 'That's self defense. You can't use that.' Then it was: 'Well, he's preventing future crimes.' That's scary, to think that they're saying it's okay for a police officer to shoot into a car because they're preventing future crime. Honestly they couldn't get beyond the fact that he's a police officer."

"They were biased," the juror said later. "I really feel like they were, because they couldn't get past the badge." She said she believes that the two jurors based their opinions on something other than the evidence that was prevented in court.

The juror said that while she was convinced that Hastings had acted unreasonably when she got into the jury room, she hadn't made up her mind whether he should be convicted of manslaughter or negligent homicide. She said several jurors were confused by the jury instructions and the law regarding manslaughter and negligent homicide, especially given that one of the jury instructions said that self-defense could not be considered as a defense in the case. Eventually, the juror said, after a very close reading of the law, many of the jurors decide that Hastings' guilt or innocence revolved around what he was thinking at the time he shot. "To me," the juror said, "not guilty would be that he had no idea and no reasonable person would have any clue that shooting into an occupied vehicle would result in serious injury or death of someone. Obviously a police officer or any reasonable person would know that shooting into an occupied vehicle is going to result in serious injury or death of someone. It doesn't matter how far away you are."

When the jury went home from deliberations the first night, the juror said, there were three people who were still voting for a not guilty verdict. The next morning, she said, there were only the two holdouts who eventually hung the jury. "They kept saying — and I'm still frustrated, I still didn't sleep last night — 'He's a police officer. They were suspects.' " the juror said. "But what stuck in our minds was: He lost sight of those suspects. He had no idea if they came on foot or in a car. Yes, he identified three black males in a car, but that could have been three black males going to work in the morning. To me, that was the unjustifiable risk: What if you're wrong?"

The juror said that during deliberations on Saturday, the majority of the jury members who were willing to convict Hastings favored the Manslaughter charge. The juror said that those jurors who favored convicting Hastings on the lesser charge of Negligent Homicide were very firm in their beliefs that he hadn't committed Manslaughter. She said that by the time the jury realized they were hopelessly deadlocked on Sunday afternoon, the ten members who were willing to convict had reached a consensus that Hastings was guilty of Negligent Homicide, based on the agreement that they couldn't be 100 percent sure of Hastings' thought process at the time of the shooting, and the fact that the jurors "knew we had to reach some kind of consensus."

The juror said that while the testimony of engineer and accident reconstructionist John Bentley was credible, she said she believed the testimony of defense reconstructionist and former Arkansas State Trooper Dale Donham "hurt the defense" because his re-enactments with a similar Honda proved that a car couldn't go up the rock slope without damage as Hastings' defense had claimed.

"That car did not go up on that slope," the juror said. "That was another thing: obviously the car was not going at 25 miles an hour, because obviously it would have gone much further up the slope. There would have been evidence of the rocks puncturing the car. It would not have just scratched. It would have punched holes in that airdam." The juror said she believed that it's possible the car "bumped the curb" and then rolled back, depending on how slow it's going, "but to me that also proved to me beyond a reasonable doubt that he had another choice that night: he could have gotten out of the way." When the other jurors told the holdouts that Hastings could have jumped out of the way instead of firing, the juror said the two replied that the dumpster beside the slope blocked Hastings' escape — something the juror Arkansas Timesspoke with said wasn't supported by the evidence that was presented.

At one point, the juror said, the ten jurors who were willing to convict became so frustrated that they considered informing the judge that the two holdouts were refusing to follow the law. "But then they came back with: 'The state didn't prove to us beyond a reasonable doubt that he acted unreasonably.' But then, that goes back to self-defense."

The juror said that she believes the testimony of Jeremiah Johnson and Keontay Walker was a mixture of "truth and lies," but said that their testimony, when connected with the forensic evidence including the wound to the left side of Bobby Moore's head, convinced her that Moore was putting the car into reverse when he was shot. She said one of the jurors made the point that "when you're trying to run something over, you're looking straight at it. I feel like he was getting ready to throw it in reverse... Hastings felt that the car was the threat. Bobby felt like Hastings was the threat, and Bobby wanted to get the heck out of there. They didn't want to get caught. I think he was getting ready to throw it in reverse." She said she thought about that when she looked over her shoulder to back out of her parking spot during the trial.

The juror called the deliberations "very, very, very frustrating," but said that the jury should have been able to reach a verdict on the evidence presented. "Nobody wants to convict a police officer," she said. "Nobody wants that. They are there to protect us, but they still have a set of rules. Like [Prosecutor Emily] Abbott said: there's rules of engagement. I feel like he broke the rules of engagement. If you can't use self-defense as a defense, it doesn't matter that you felt that the car was coming toward you."

View Original Article: arktimes.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source arktimes.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Hastings juror speaks:..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"b","i":"1274313","t":"Commonwealth chief on five-day visit to Sri Lanka - Yahoo News India","a":1},{"b":"d","i":"960110","t":"Mobile phones can play role in longevity: study","a":2},{"b":"b","i":"1274294","t":"Khlo\u00e9 Kardashian wants closure","a":3},{"b":"c","i":"1884173","t":"How social media followings can boost you at work","a":4},{"b":"c","i":"1884175","t":"Weekend reads: Russell Brand's Revolution and Joy Division's Ian Curtis gets lyrical","a":5},{"b":"a","i":"1336177","t":"ELECTION 2014: Steve McCarter, Robert Gillies vie for 154th legislative district seat","a":6},{"b":"a","i":"1336135","t":"Clues to how people bounce back from surgery","a":7},{"b":"b","i":"1274228","t":"Wootton holiday camp decision","a":8},{"b":"d","i":"960020","t":"No shortcut to success, youths told","a":9},{"b":"a","i":"1336071","t":"Concorde’s Cambridge-built nose droop’s again thanks to work by The Duxford Aviation Society","a":10},{"b":"f","i":"1157726","t":"Yost's faith, sixth-inning moves work for Royals","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1274170","t":"School trustee candidate: Dot Neary","a":12},{"b":"b","i":"1274142","t":"OSHE Consultants - Creating a Mindful HSE Organization","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1274145","t":"Vehicle destroyed after suspected arson attack at industrial estate","a":14},{"b":"b","i":"1274146","t":"New from Akro-Mils: Crystal Clear AkroBin® Dividers","a":15},{"b":"a","i":"1335961","t":"National Pavement Expo Pavement Trade Show to include Pavement Layers & WheelitOff | Paving & Sealcoating Sales Process & Software to Make Your Business Better","a":16},{"b":"d","i":"959920","t":"Vote for the Best European 3PL \u2013 Here's Why","a":17},{"b":"a","i":"1335938","t":"Manipur artisans work towards preserving traditional handicrafts - Yahoo News India","a":18},{"b":"c","i":"1884080","t":"Lakers stay upbeat in spite of loss in final preseason game","a":19},{"b":"a","i":"1335927","t":"Eperience works wonders with Hooked","a":20},{"b":"c","i":"1884063","t":"Costumed cross country run to raise money for Bronx trails","a":21},{"b":"b","i":"1274108","t":"School trustee candidate: Mark Robinson","a":22},{"b":"d","i":"959890","t":"Corrie's Marc not heading to LA","a":23},{"b":"d","i":"959891","t":"Australian Ebola response 'shambles': AMA","a":24},{"b":"b","i":"1274087","t":"Back in the Bay Area, Guthrie gets Series win","a":25},{"b":"a","i":"1335906","t":"Melbourne Festival review: Imaginative work unleashes wild energies","a":26},{"b":"b","i":"1274056","t":"Holmstrom lauds JCCI work - Yahoo Maktoob News","a":27},{"b":"c","i":"1884051","t":"Ghosn Expects More Recalls as Carmakers Fight for Buyers","a":28},{"b":"b","i":"1274040","t":"The holiday spirit","a":29},{"b":"c","i":"1884035","t":"16 killed in China coal mine collapse","a":30},{"b":"f","i":"1157676","t":"Overweight Women More Likely To Have Low-Paying Jobs Than Overweight Men","a":31},{"b":"b","i":"1273950","t":"ELECTION 2014: Harper, Leonard vie for 61st District seat","a":32},{"b":"a","i":"1335859","t":"Manning miffed at scoreboard operator","a":33},{"b":"b","i":"1273970","t":"Longview to spend $5.8 million on sewage plant","a":34},{"b":"b","i":"1273972","t":"Lessons That Can Be Learned From Marijuana Legalization in US","a":35},{"b":"b","i":"1273990","t":"Jackson Co. 35, East Jackson 15: Tuck, Lewis lead Panther win over Eagles","a":36},{"b":"b","i":"1273993","t":"Debate over compromise shapes Georgia Senate race","a":37},{"b":"c","i":"1884009","t":"stltoday.com","a":38},{"b":"b","i":"1273910","t":"Bears win in four sets","a":39},{"b":"c","i":"1883998","t":"Debate over compromise shapes Georgia Senate race","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1273923","t":"Warhol Bodyguard Sued Over \u2018Liz\u2019","a":41},{"b":"a","i":"1335782","t":"British singer and activist Elton John joins with US agencies on new AIDS program","a":42},{"b":"c","i":"1883984","t":"16 killed in coal mine collapse in northwestern China","a":43},{"b":"b","i":"1273904","t":"Historic State Street in Newtown expands by three new businesses, made official by ribbon cuttings","a":44},{"b":"c","i":"1883977","t":"Bayonne mayor: Fire was contained to roof of Bayonne Medical Center","a":45},{"b":"b","i":"1273864","t":"Newtown Supervisors to ask planning commission for input on whether to save, demolish or relocate historic Villas\u2019 farmhouse","a":46},{"b":"b","i":"1273866","t":"God\u2019s Love Lutheran in Newtown working to transform \u2018the CAN\u2019 into medical clinic","a":47},{"b":"b","i":"1273874","t":"NH widening work gets going, finally","a":48},{"b":"b","i":"1273876","t":"Festival celebrating journalistic courage","a":49},{"b":"b","i":"1273860","t":"Newtown Supervisors to ask planning commission for input on whether to save, demolish or relocate historic Villas\u2019 farmhouse","a":50},{"b":"b","i":"1273822","t":"Debate continues over fate of Villas farmhouse in Newtown as developer proposes moving it to Newtown-Yardley Road","a":51},{"b":"b","i":"1273828","t":"| Valley News","a":52},{"b":"e","i":"530059","t":"Spotting Autism at 18 Months","a":53},{"b":"a","i":"1335687","t":"News Kono Danshi, Sekka ni Nayandemasu English-Subtitled in Japan","a":54},{"b":"a","i":"1335689","t":"A Closer Look At The Children's Advocacy Center","a":55},{"b":"b","i":"1273767","t":"Smarter Supply","a":56},{"b":"b","i":"1273758","t":"Firefighters in England set to walk out for four days next Friday","a":57},{"b":"c","i":"1883907","t":"French explorer La Salle\u2019s ship sails into Austin museum","a":58},{"b":"a","i":"1335642","t":"‘Guardians Of The Galaxy 2:’ Peter Quill’s Dad And Time Travel","a":59},{"b":"a","i":"1335625","t":"Police: DNA links Carver man to 2010 Rehoboth, Swansea break-ins - News - The Herald News, Fall River, MA - Fall River, MA","a":60},{"b":"a","i":"1335637","t":"TV Guide - Damian Lewis and Paul Giamatti Will Star in Showtime's Wall Street Drama Billions - News - Moberly Monitor-Index - Moberly, MO - Moberly, MO","a":61},{"b":"c","i":"1883879","t":"Back in the Bay Area, Guthrie gets Series win","a":62},{"b":"b","i":"1273648","t":"Touch Screen Tech Issues May Have Changed Woman's Vote on Ballot","a":63},{"b":"a","i":"1335594","t":"Terrifying unknown lay beyond walls for MPs - Revelstoke Times Review","a":64},{"b":"a","i":"1335595","t":"House Speaker orders Hill security review - Revelstoke Times Review","a":65},{"b":"b","i":"1273636","t":"MFK in Lakeview inspired by food writer, summer and Spain","a":66},{"b":"a","i":"1335597","t":"Liberal Democrats would allow safe standing at football","a":67},{"b":"a","i":"1335566","t":"Benedictine changes educational course, to focus on nontraditional students - News - The State Journal-Register - Springfield, IL","a":68},{"b":"a","i":"1335567","t":"TV Guide - ABC's Manhattan Love Story Is the First Cancellation of the 2014-2015 Season - News - Moberly Monitor-Index - Moberly, MO - Moberly, MO","a":69},{"b":"d","i":"959771","t":"Shaikh Zayed Road diversion from Saturday","a":70},{"b":"d","i":"959753","t":"A Stage Set for Savoring Autumn in New York","a":71},{"b":"a","i":"1335505","t":"Patients make an impact in Prince Albert Parkland Health Region - Local - The Prince Albert Daily Herald","a":72},{"b":"a","i":"1335522","t":"Lawyer, passersby go to fallen soldier's aid - Revelstoke Times Review","a":73},{"b":"a","i":"1335496","t":"WHO: Millions of Ebola vaccine doses ready in 2015","a":74},{"b":"d","i":"959739","t":"Newest Attack Submarine to Be Commissioned by US Navy on Saturday: Pentagon","a":75},{"b":"a","i":"1335478","t":"Neil surprised after 'reinventing wheel'","a":76},{"b":"a","i":"1335408","t":"Sioux Falls teacher wins award, $25,000 prize","a":77},{"b":"a","i":"1335412","t":"Benefit cuts causing hardship for working people in York","a":78},{"b":"a","i":"1335421","t":"The Real Ted Bishop","a":79},{"b":"a","i":"1335429","t":"Overworking has high costs","a":80},{"b":"a","i":"1335307","t":"Farmington mayor says no to mandatory animal registration","a":81},{"b":"c","i":"1883722","t":"Lava creeps toward road on Hawaii\u2019s Big Island","a":82},{"b":"d","i":"959706","t":"Draghi warns eurozone at critical phase","a":83},{"b":"a","i":"1335274","t":"Unreported news","a":84},{"b":"a","i":"1335264","t":"The Valory Music Co. Recording Artist RaeLynn will Join Boston Brass to Perform at the National Association for Music Education Conference","a":85},{"b":"d","i":"959682","t":"Google teams up with Oxford to teach machines to think like humans","a":86},{"b":"d","i":"959652","t":"Court hears mom\u2019s hijack horror","a":87},{"b":"d","i":"959654","t":"Mall developer threatens to sue Sisulu","a":88},{"b":"c","i":"1883662","t":"New York Doctor With Ebola Was Quick to Volunteer Overseas","a":89},{"b":"e","i":"529977","t":"Listen: Monica Potter describes the perfect 'Parenthood' ending","a":90},{"b":"e","i":"529969","t":"Must-See Projects at Prospect New Orleans, a Citywide Art Biennial","a":91},{"b":"d","i":"959551","t":"Gray Urges Feds Not to Compromise Walter Reed Plans","a":92},{"b":"d","i":"959488","t":"Rollins, Konerko named Clemente Award winners","a":93},{"b":"d","i":"959512","t":"Aquinas grad who helped name Ebola: We didn't realize deadliness","a":94},{"b":"d","i":"959514","t":"Commentary: Football scandals and the Nobel Prize in Economics","a":95},{"b":"c","i":"1883616","t":"Federal employees unhappy with senior leaders, suffer low moral, survey shows","a":96},{"b":"c","i":"1883595","t":"Kathleen Henderson's drawings are as searing and tough as ever","a":97},{"b":"d","i":"959459","t":"United Nations gong for The Courier","a":98},{"b":"d","i":"959460","t":"CVs a crucial part of any job application","a":99},{"b":"f","i":"1157375","t":"MnDOT snowplow drivers prepare for upcoming winter snowfall","a":100}]

      100

      Commonwealth chief on five-day visit to Sri Lanka - Yahoo News India