English | Italian

"How to Gauge the Price of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
Christopher Johnson's - Urban League of Portland Youth Employment Summer Program Graduate Interview
American Graduate Champion: Marty Johnson (NJTV)
Jacqueline Novogratz of Acumen Speaks with Johnson Graduate School.
ABIC2014 - Peter Phillips, U of S Johnson-Shoyama Graduate School of Public Policy
Ron Johnson: Trust in Your Imagination and Instinct
Steeler and Centerville graduate Will Johnson back home for kids camp
Continue »
Pop theme

Bibeau,Europe budget,Elizabeth II,Ebola Virus,Carswell,Marysville,Dilma Rousseff,Jeffrey Fowle,Taylor Swift,Zellweger

Related theme

How to Gauge the Price of Danger


graduate johnson school

2013-11-30 17:56:44

True or false? An investment banker who’s thrilled about his new twin-engine Cessna will be just as excited about it after discovering that his summer neighbor on Nantucket commutes there in a Gulfstream intercontinental jet.

If you answered “true,” you are in tune with the models that underlie most modern economic analysis. Those models assume that people care only about the absolute quantity and quality of the goods they consume. So the investment banker would still be happy with his twin-engine plane, no matter what his neighbor was flying. Yet in the real world, context matters. As the economist Richard Layard wrote, “In a poor country a man proves to his wife that he loves her by giving her a rose, but in a rich country he must give a dozen roses.”

Context shapes our

    No results related

    Add now

evaluations more heavily for some goods than for others, an asymmetry that can distort our decisions. That simple fact is the key to understanding many otherwise puzzling real-world spending patterns. It also helps explain why we should support regulations that limit our freedom to act in specific ways.

Consider the familiar trade-off between wages and workplace safety. Because safety devices are expensive, additional safety means lower wages. Reducing risk to zero is impossible, so the practical question must always be this: How much safety is enough? Since Adam Smith’s day, classical economic theory has held that well-informed workers in competitive markets will navigate this trade-off sensibly. They will accept additional risk in return for higher pay only if the satisfaction resulting from their additional buying power is greater than the corresponding loss in satisfaction from reduced safety. Regulations that mandate higher safety levels make workers worse off by forcing them to buy safety they value at less than its cost.

That’s the theory, anyway.

But why, then, does virtually every country in the world regulate workplace safety? (Even the poorest countries have at least rudimentary safety requirements.) Classical economic theory doesn’t have a good answer. It either portrays such regulations as anomalous, or else needed only because workers are uninformed or markets aren’t competitive enough. Yet we regulate many safety risks that workers clearly understand, and most safety regulations have their greatest impact in precisely those markets that most closely approximate the competitive ideal.

The mystery is resolved when we remember that context shapes evaluations of safety less heavily than it does for other goods — say, housing. In that case, even well-informed workers in perfectly competitive markets will tend to buy too little safety on their own. The forces that underlie this distortion are captured in a pair of thought experiments involving choices between two environments.

In World A, your family lives in a 4,000-square-foot house, while everyone else lives in 6,000-square-foot houses. In World B, you live in a 3,000-square-foot house, while everyone else has to make do with just 2,500 square feet. If conditions were otherwise identical and would forever remain, which would you choose?

Classical economics, which says that only absolute values matter, portrays World A as the correct choice, because you would have a larger house there. But when researchers confront real people with variations on this hypothetical decision, most of them choose B. Once houses expand past a certain size, it seems, relative advantage trumps absolute size.

Now suppose you need to choose between levels of workplace safety. In World A, you would have a two-in-100,000 chance of dying on the job this year, while everyone else has a one-in-100,000 chance. In World B, you would have a four-in-100,000 chance of dying, versus a six-in-100,000 chance for everyone else.

Death is sobering. Again, the choice is between absolute and relative advantage, but this time almost everyone chooses World A. For safety, it seems, choice patterns affirm the classical theory’s assumption that only absolute quantities matter.

Here is where it gets tricky: Relative advantage matters more for housing than for safety, so markets won’t sustain an optimal trade-off between the two. Suppose a worker accepts a slightly riskier job for slightly higher pay. The extra money buys a house whose size, in absolute terms, isn’t enough to compensate for the reduction in safety. But that house is larger in relative terms, too, and that makes the difference. Now the exchange is attractive on balance.

Similar incentives apply to everyone else, though, so when all workers sacrifice safety in the hope of buying a relatively larger house, no one moves forward. They are like spectators in a sporting event: All stand to get a better view, yet no one sees any better than before.

The problem isn’t that workers are ill-informed, or that markets are insufficiently competitive. Even with full knowledge, there just isn’t much that workers can do to change matters on their own.

Consider safety regulations in hockey. Helmets are required, even in the National Hockey League but that’s a fairly recent development. Many players had believed that they could see and hear better without them. But when everyone skated without helmets, the relative advantage disappeared, resulting in gratuitous risk of injury to all players. In 1979, the N.H.L. required all newly hired players to wear helmets, but veterans were exempted. Some continued to skate without a helmet until 1997, believing that it gave them an edge — but today’s players seem to see futility in sacrificing safety for an unsustainable relative advantage.

We all value freedom. But while classical economics encourages the complaint that safety regulations violate workers’ freedom, that complaint is misguided. It is little different from complaining that helmet rules violate athletes’ freedom. Of course they do — but with athletes as with workers, that’s precisely what people wanted.

ROBERT H. FRANK is an economics professor at the Johnson Graduate School of Management at Cornell University.

View Original Article: nytimes.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source nytimes.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"How to Gauge the Price of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"a","i":"1337751","t":"Myer relaunches brand as Clemenger BBDO Melbourne devises ‘find wonderful’ campaign","a":1},{"b":"c","i":"1885556","t":"Brazilians Vote for Leader as Polls Show Nation Divided","a":2},{"b":"c","i":"1885528","t":"Hillary: "Business Does Not Create Jobs", Washington Does","a":3},{"b":"e","i":"530377","t":"NYC Ebola Patient\u2019s Fiancee to Leave for Home Quarantine","a":4},{"b":"d","i":"961777","t":"Counting every drop: Los Angeles-area company helps Peninsula customers save water","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1275774","t":"HP Broadens Moonshot Portfolio to New Applications for Increased Efficiency and Lower Cost","a":6},{"b":"d","i":"961761","t":"Irish artist suffers serious injuries in Limerick road crash","a":7},{"b":"b","i":"1275749","t":"It's okay to not be perfect: Huma Qureshi","a":8},{"b":"a","i":"1337589","t":"ROAR for America","a":9},{"b":"d","i":"961717","t":"Camels snapped enjoying the sun - on a Hampshire beach!","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1337660","t":"UFC 179 results: Wilson Reis finishes Scott Jorgensen in first round","a":11},{"b":"a","i":"1337661","t":"Brazil To Elect President Amid Corruption Claim - Yahoo News UK","a":12},{"b":"a","i":"1337662","t":"Merry Murray | The Sunday Times","a":13},{"b":"a","i":"1337669","t":"I love edgy style \u2014 Utee Rone","a":14},{"b":"d","i":"961847","t":"Biden denounces 'cockamamie' Republican values at Vernon Hills rally","a":15},{"b":"a","i":"1337550","t":"\u2018Jom Heboh\u2019 celebrity auction today - Yahoo News Malaysia","a":16},{"b":"a","i":"1337551","t":"SA Pets Alive! celebrates opening of adoption center","a":17},{"b":"d","i":"961672","t":"Comment: Politics can't hold enterprise to ransom","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1275789","t":"Rougaroo Festival draws crowds for a cause","a":19},{"b":"b","i":"1275675","t":"Sexual boosting oil seized with booze pedlar","a":20},{"b":"b","i":"1275791","t":"Lieberman Software Privilege Management Platform Now Includes SSH Key Management","a":21},{"b":"f","i":"1159087","t":"Jack Bruce, bassist of 60's band Cream, dies at 71","a":22},{"b":"a","i":"1337610","t":"Meet @ActiveState Nov 4-6 @DevOpsSummit Silicon Valley [#DevOps]","a":23},{"b":"c","i":"1885295","t":"Illinois Joins NY, NJ With Ebola Risk-Flier Quarantines","a":24},{"b":"f","i":"1159130","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":25},{"b":"a","i":"1337515","t":"\u2018Vote Walker for governor\u2019 - Beloit Daily News: Opinion","a":26},{"b":"e","i":"530329","t":"Premier Analysis: Hammers and Saints flying high as Man City and Liverpool stutter","a":27},{"b":"d","i":"961549","t":"Brand SRK now a trade mark","a":28},{"b":"d","i":"961568","t":"Government clears defence projects worth Rs 80,000 crores","a":29},{"b":"a","i":"1337504","t":"Items filtered by date: Friday, 24 October 2014","a":30},{"b":"b","i":"1275600","t":"Betsy-Tacy Society Dedicates a Hitching Block","a":31},{"b":"d","i":"961529","t":"Activist Leaflets From South Korea Threaten Fragile Truce With North Korea","a":32},{"b":"d","i":"961525","t":"Pikmin Shorts Coming to the 3DS","a":33},{"b":"d","i":"961518","t":"Final Fantasy 14 Getting Flying Mounts, Personal Airships and More","a":34},{"b":"e","i":"530323","t":"Apple Cores Are a Myth","a":35},{"b":"d","i":"961465","t":"SHCI weakens further; SZCI up 0.5%","a":36},{"b":"d","i":"961447","t":"Defending champ Hend pulls clear with 67","a":37},{"b":"a","i":"1337451","t":"Ukraine Votes in Wartime Ballot Set to Back Pro-EU Forces","a":38},{"b":"d","i":"961402","t":"CTA bomb screening is a waste","a":39},{"b":"d","i":"961370","t":"Top 10 city cars: a gift to urbanites from the god of small things","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1275552","t":"Irish artist John Shinnors injured in Limerick road accident","a":41},{"b":"d","i":"961375","t":"Tributes pour in after Jack Bruce, known for his work with Eric Clapton in 1960s group Cream, dies at home in Suffolk","a":42},{"b":"d","i":"961384","t":"Sears store closure a big opportunity for Bayshore","a":43},{"b":"d","i":"961386","t":"Can Kathryn Bufano save Boston Store?","a":44},{"b":"c","i":"1885156","t":"Christie defends Ebola quarantine announcement, saying he's trying to protect N.J. residents","a":45},{"b":"a","i":"1337423","t":"NYC Ebola Patient\u2019s Fiancee to Leave for Home Quarantine","a":46},{"b":"d","i":"961346","t":"SATURDAY'S WEATHER FORECAST: Sunshine, warming into the mid-60s","a":47},{"b":"b","i":"1275502","t":"HK & China Snapshot Research","a":48},{"b":"b","i":"1275505","t":"We'd better hope God's looking out for US","a":49},{"b":"a","i":"1337384","t":"Speed plays role in early morning accident","a":50},{"b":"a","i":"1337385","t":"Motorcyclist in critical condition after early morning wreck","a":51},{"b":"a","i":"1337386","t":"Police searching for hit-and-run driver","a":52},{"b":"d","i":"961246","t":"Journalists over-rely on official sources, hears conference","a":53},{"b":"a","i":"1337359","t":"Liverpool FC 0-0 Hull City: What we learned from the stalemate at Anfield","a":54},{"b":"c","i":"1885079","t":"Twitter Acquires Photo-Sharing Website Twitpic's Domain And Photo Archive","a":55},{"b":"d","i":"961231","t":"add. formats","a":56},{"b":"a","i":"1337292","t":"‘Transparent’ Creator Jill Soloway Envisions Five Seasons For Amazon Series","a":57},{"b":"a","i":"1337294","t":"Seattle Seahawks promote WR Phil Bates, put Derrick Coleman on IR","a":58},{"b":"a","i":"1337281","t":"Sick Wild-Blues have similar symptoms; Koivu on faceoff kickouts; Olofsson has shoulder surgery; Brodziak keeps head up | Russo's Rants | StarTribune.com","a":59},{"b":"a","i":"1337262","t":"Murdaca races clear at Royal Melbourne","a":60},{"b":"d","i":"961102","t":"Saints go second, misfiring Reds draw and errors condemn Sunderland to another loss","a":61},{"b":"d","i":"961106","t":"Gascoigne 'sectioned after binge'","a":62},{"b":"d","i":"961086","t":"Home Ministry to Send Advisories to States on Racially Motivated Incidents: Kiren Rijiju","a":63},{"b":"d","i":"961072","t":"For News on BJP-Sena Reunion, All Eyes on PM Modi's High Tea Today","a":64},{"b":"a","i":"1337237","t":"Review: 'Midnight in Siberia,' by David Greene | Star Tribune","a":65},{"b":"a","i":"1337241","t":"UnityPoint at Home named to 2014 HomeCare Elite","a":66},{"b":"a","i":"1337242","t":"McCoy, Bucs agree to $95.2 million contract","a":67},{"b":"f","i":"1158524","t":"Surgeons At Comer Children's Hospital Work For Free To Fix Kids' Birth Defects, Deformities","a":68},{"b":"a","i":"1337222","t":"Sen. Kirk Works With Students To Develop Anti-Bullying Game App","a":69},{"b":"d","i":"961002","t":"Local beauty hopes to wow judges at international pageant","a":70},{"b":"e","i":"530250","t":"So Who Does Create Jobs?","a":71},{"b":"d","i":"960937","t":"NC riverfront voted best in America","a":72},{"b":"d","i":"960950","t":"Around the Web: New evidence in Michael Brown's shooting","a":73},{"b":"b","i":"1275339","t":"Cream guitarist Jack Bruce dies","a":74},{"b":"d","i":"960929","t":"A New Plugin Entitled Proglyph was Announced Today from Pixel Film Studios for Final Cut Pro X","a":75},{"b":"d","i":"960922","t":"Triton Algae Innovations Ltd. Names Dr. Xun Wang as President","a":76},{"b":"b","i":"1275314","t":"Subscriber Services","a":77},{"b":"c","i":"1884906","t":"Buffalo police search Cazenovia Creek for missing man","a":78},{"b":"d","i":"960903","t":"Marriage proposal to Imran still stands: Meera","a":79},{"b":"c","i":"1884891","t":"stltoday.com","a":80},{"b":"b","i":"1275279","t":"Birmingham City fans fury at players and owners after record 8 - 0 home defeat to Bournemouth","a":81},{"b":"c","i":"1884885","t":"Cafeteria Worker Tried Stopping Washington School Shooter","a":82},{"b":"f","i":"1158443","t":"Sounders FC vs. L.A. Galaxy, pre-match notes and lineups","a":83},{"b":"c","i":"1884850","t":"Hong Kong Tensions Rise Between Protesters, Opposition","a":84},{"b":"f","i":"1158287","t":"Real recover to see off Barcelona","a":85},{"b":"a","i":"1337136","t":"County jobless rate drops to 8.3 percent","a":86},{"b":"c","i":"1884834","t":"Calif. mourns loss of 2 deputies killed in crime spree","a":87},{"b":"e","i":"530219","t":"The SEO Secrets Every Business Should Know","a":88},{"b":"f","i":"1158302","t":"Liverpool v Hull, Sunderland v Arsenal, West Brom v Crystal Palace, Southampton v Stoke Premier League as it happened","a":89},{"b":"a","i":"1337119","t":"Sports' contributions cherished: CE","a":90},{"b":"c","i":"1884795","t":"Fiancee's Family Confident in Medical Care Ebola Doctor Receiving","a":91},{"b":"e","i":"530207","t":"Alice bands and headbands: hair accessories for fall\/winter 2014\/2015","a":92},{"b":"f","i":"1158363","t":"Neil Cavuto Delivers Moving Tribute to Late Fox Anchor Terry Keenan","a":93},{"b":"c","i":"1884762","t":"Tribes in Central Yemen Join Forces Against Houthi Rebels","a":94},{"b":"c","i":"1884763","t":"Squabble Over $100 Billion Aid Stalls Global Warming Deal","a":95},{"b":"a","i":"1337084","t":"Difficult qualifying for Honda at Suzuka","a":96},{"b":"b","i":"1275186","t":"Breakers import Ibekwe aims to bounce back","a":97},{"b":"b","i":"1275166","t":"SPORTS BRIEFS: Chicken BBQ for Jallen Oct. 26","a":98},{"b":"b","i":"1275151","t":"Tributes mount up after death of six-year-old boy in West Derby","a":99},{"b":"b","i":"1275152","t":"Pedestrian critically injured after he was struck by off-duty Garda","a":100}]

      100

      Myer relaunches brand as Clemenger BBDO Melbourne devises ‘find wonderful’ campaign