English | Italian

"How to Gauge the Price of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

show list
related videos
Jacqueline Novogratz of Acumen Speaks with Johnson Graduate School.
ABIC2014 - Peter Phillips, U of S Johnson-Shoyama Graduate School of Public Policy
Ron Johnson: Trust in Your Imagination and Instinct
WCSCC Graduate Corey Johnson Recites Pi to 100 digits
How to Apply to Graduate School
Welcome message from Owen Dean M. Eric Johnson
Continue »
Pop theme

Scottish independence,Suicide Bomber,Taliban,David Haines,Alex Salmond,Alan Pardew,Flight Attendants,Miss America,Django Unchained,Danny Welbeck

Related theme

How to Gauge the Price of Danger

graduate johnson school

2013-11-30 17:56:44

True or false? An investment banker who’s thrilled about his new twin-engine Cessna will be just as excited about it after discovering that his summer neighbor on Nantucket commutes there in a Gulfstream intercontinental jet.

If you answered “true,” you are in tune with the models that underlie most modern economic analysis. Those models assume that people care only about the absolute quantity and quality of the goods they consume. So the investment banker would still be happy with his twin-engine plane, no matter what his neighbor was flying. Yet in the real world, context matters. As the economist Richard Layard wrote, “In a poor country a man proves to his wife that he loves her by giving her a rose, but in a rich country he must give a dozen roses.”

Context shapes our

    No results related

    Add now

evaluations more heavily for some goods than for others, an asymmetry that can distort our decisions. That simple fact is the key to understanding many otherwise puzzling real-world spending patterns. It also helps explain why we should support regulations that limit our freedom to act in specific ways.

Consider the familiar trade-off between wages and workplace safety. Because safety devices are expensive, additional safety means lower wages. Reducing risk to zero is impossible, so the practical question must always be this: How much safety is enough? Since Adam Smith’s day, classical economic theory has held that well-informed workers in competitive markets will navigate this trade-off sensibly. They will accept additional risk in return for higher pay only if the satisfaction resulting from their additional buying power is greater than the corresponding loss in satisfaction from reduced safety. Regulations that mandate higher safety levels make workers worse off by forcing them to buy safety they value at less than its cost.

That’s the theory, anyway.

But why, then, does virtually every country in the world regulate workplace safety? (Even the poorest countries have at least rudimentary safety requirements.) Classical economic theory doesn’t have a good answer. It either portrays such regulations as anomalous, or else needed only because workers are uninformed or markets aren’t competitive enough. Yet we regulate many safety risks that workers clearly understand, and most safety regulations have their greatest impact in precisely those markets that most closely approximate the competitive ideal.

The mystery is resolved when we remember that context shapes evaluations of safety less heavily than it does for other goods — say, housing. In that case, even well-informed workers in perfectly competitive markets will tend to buy too little safety on their own. The forces that underlie this distortion are captured in a pair of thought experiments involving choices between two environments.

In World A, your family lives in a 4,000-square-foot house, while everyone else lives in 6,000-square-foot houses. In World B, you live in a 3,000-square-foot house, while everyone else has to make do with just 2,500 square feet. If conditions were otherwise identical and would forever remain, which would you choose?

Classical economics, which says that only absolute values matter, portrays World A as the correct choice, because you would have a larger house there. But when researchers confront real people with variations on this hypothetical decision, most of them choose B. Once houses expand past a certain size, it seems, relative advantage trumps absolute size.

Now suppose you need to choose between levels of workplace safety. In World A, you would have a two-in-100,000 chance of dying on the job this year, while everyone else has a one-in-100,000 chance. In World B, you would have a four-in-100,000 chance of dying, versus a six-in-100,000 chance for everyone else.

Death is sobering. Again, the choice is between absolute and relative advantage, but this time almost everyone chooses World A. For safety, it seems, choice patterns affirm the classical theory’s assumption that only absolute quantities matter.

Here is where it gets tricky: Relative advantage matters more for housing than for safety, so markets won’t sustain an optimal trade-off between the two. Suppose a worker accepts a slightly riskier job for slightly higher pay. The extra money buys a house whose size, in absolute terms, isn’t enough to compensate for the reduction in safety. But that house is larger in relative terms, too, and that makes the difference. Now the exchange is attractive on balance.

Similar incentives apply to everyone else, though, so when all workers sacrifice safety in the hope of buying a relatively larger house, no one moves forward. They are like spectators in a sporting event: All stand to get a better view, yet no one sees any better than before.

The problem isn’t that workers are ill-informed, or that markets are insufficiently competitive. Even with full knowledge, there just isn’t much that workers can do to change matters on their own.

Consider safety regulations in hockey. Helmets are required, even in the National Hockey League but that’s a fairly recent development. Many players had believed that they could see and hear better without them. But when everyone skated without helmets, the relative advantage disappeared, resulting in gratuitous risk of injury to all players. In 1979, the N.H.L. required all newly hired players to wear helmets, but veterans were exempted. Some continued to skate without a helmet until 1997, believing that it gave them an edge — but today’s players seem to see futility in sacrificing safety for an unsustainable relative advantage.

We all value freedom. But while classical economics encourages the complaint that safety regulations violate workers’ freedom, that complaint is misguided. It is little different from complaining that helmet rules violate athletes’ freedom. Of course they do — but with athletes as with workers, that’s precisely what people wanted.

ROBERT H. FRANK is an economics professor at the Johnson Graduate School of Management at Cornell University.

View Original Article: nytimes.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source nytimes.com.
Or contact us


Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

[{"b":"c","i":"1813581","t":"TIPS Lag Behind Conventional Treasuries Before CPI, Fed Report","a":1},{"b":"b","i":"1195166","t":"US organizing summit on UN peacekeeping next week","a":2},{"b":"b","i":"1195152","t":"Chief Justice Ivor Archie's keynote at the start of the 2014 Law Term","a":3},{"b":"b","i":"1195139","t":"Downspout Goalpost defends homes from the elements\r\nInnovations","a":4},{"b":"b","i":"1195118","t":"Strong economy? Yeah, right!","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1195079","t":"Peter Burling and Blair Tuke show class in Spain","a":6},{"b":"b","i":"1195081","t":"Kathleen Baker’s Backstroke Prowess Headed To Berkeley Next Fall","a":7},{"b":"e","i":"502139","t":"Poverty Keeps Getting Worse and Worse for Working-Age Adults | Mother Jones","a":8},{"b":"e","i":"502140","t":"The Endless Rabbit Hole of Secession, Shetland Islands Edition | Mother Jones","a":9},{"b":"b","i":"1195032","t":"Apple’s iPhone 6 And 6 Plus Cases Offer Comfort And Light Protection With Few Concessions","a":10},{"b":"c","i":"1813488","t":"US organizing summit on UN peacekeeping next week","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1195012","t":"Dates Set for PG&E Quarterly Stock Dividends","a":12},{"b":"b","i":"1195019","t":"Clorox Declares Regular Quarterly Dividend of 74 Cents per Share","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1194973","t":"Final day of campaign before vote - Yahoo News UK","a":14},{"b":"b","i":"1194979","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":15},{"b":"b","i":"1194980","t":"Kenshoo Acquires Adquant to Bolster Social and Mobile Marketing SaaS Offering - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":16},{"b":"b","i":"1194959","t":"Volconologist: Only a Matter of Time when next Eruption Starts","a":17},{"b":"e","i":"502110","t":"\u201cI\u2019m Relieved That 70 Percent of People Believe Our Homeland Is Threatened\u201d","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1194939","t":"Fort Worth council approves $1.5 billion budget","a":19},{"b":"b","i":"1194946","t":"How to build more homes: MEASZ\u2019s strategy","a":20},{"b":"c","i":"1813444","t":"Watch Touching Moment Firefighters Find Wedding Rings in Burned Down California House","a":21},{"b":"f","i":"1068325","t":"Peterson no stranger to 'whuppings'","a":22},{"b":"e","i":"502078","t":"Strange, Gorgeous Art Made From Single-Cell Organisms Under a Microscope","a":23},{"b":"b","i":"1194872","t":"iPhone 6 Plus Review: The First Truly Well-Designed Big Smartphone","a":24},{"b":"b","i":"1194886","t":"‘Dungeons & Dragons’ Movie Rights Trial Starts With Roll Of The Sequel Dice","a":25},{"b":"b","i":"1194888","t":"At The Movies sees extra 168,000 tune in following news of show’s axing","a":26},{"b":"f","i":"1068263","t":"Site Search","a":27},{"b":"f","i":"1068245","t":"Friends, family recall whippings to Peterson","a":28},{"b":"b","i":"1194856","t":"Street gangs tone down use of colors, tattoos","a":29},{"b":"b","i":"1194804","t":"HDR 2014: Are they listening?","a":30},{"b":"d","i":"856189","t":"Businessman tears down mob villa","a":31},{"b":"f","i":"1068250","t":"Morning Jolt: Adrian Peterson accused of abusing another child","a":32},{"b":"b","i":"1194784","t":"California Starts Issuing Self-Driving Car Permits","a":33},{"b":"b","i":"1194788","t":"Court Tosses $368.2M Patent Fine Against Apple","a":34},{"b":"b","i":"1194789","t":"Microsoft OneNote Launches on Android Wear","a":35},{"b":"f","i":"1068231","t":"RAW Viewership Down, WWE Stock Down, Jericho Talking to TNA Team","a":36},{"b":"b","i":"1194776","t":"Featured Brokers","a":37},{"b":"b","i":"1194778","t":"Jarome Iginla (and most every other Avalanche veteran) skates Tuesday","a":38},{"b":"c","i":"1813359","t":"Watch Cable News Anchors Read Rihanna’s ‘F*ck You’ CBS Tweet On Air","a":39},{"b":"e","i":"502045","t":"The One Lie That Brought Down Walmart's PR Chief","a":40},{"b":"e","i":"502049","t":"Market Is Priced for Gradual Tightening: Pimco","a":41},{"b":"b","i":"1194757","t":"Electrical Steel Producers Appeal USITC Decision In Trade Case, Says Kelley Drye & Warren LLP","a":42},{"b":"d","i":"856079","t":"Political parties make power play","a":43},{"b":"b","i":"1194731","t":"Ghosts of Bethlehem Steel still linger in Philadelphia soccer lore | THE WORD","a":44},{"b":"b","i":"1194732","t":"Your Top Plays for Today","a":45},{"b":"b","i":"1194743","t":"Galatasaray salvage late draw against Anderlecht","a":46},{"b":"e","i":"502019","t":"NASA Awards Boeing And SpaceX Contracts To Deliver Astronauts To The Space Station","a":47},{"b":"c","i":"1813335","t":"Polaroid Socialmatic","a":48},{"b":"b","i":"1194693","t":"Breaking News - GSN and Jerry Springer Taking \"Baggage on the Road\" in New Traveling Spinoff of Hit Dating Game Show \"Baggage\" | TheFutonCritic.com","a":49},{"b":"d","i":"856044","t":"Claman on Call: All Eyes on the Fed","a":50},{"b":"e","i":"502007","t":"NASA Taps Boeing, SpaceX to Transport Astronauts to Space Station","a":51},{"b":"c","i":"1813314","t":"Cops: Wrong dog killed by man upset over barking","a":52},{"b":"d","i":"855998","t":"Arizona Commerce Authority and Arizona Technology Council Launch the new TechConnect: Arizona's Technology Magazine","a":53},{"b":"c","i":"1813291","t":"Poll: Scott Peters and Carl DeMaio tied in 52nd Congressional District election","a":54},{"b":"d","i":"855976","t":"Welcome to: Wednesday, September 17, 2014","a":55},{"b":"d","i":"855988","t":"Yesterdays Sept. 17","a":56},{"b":"d","i":"855948","t":"Roundabout Sept. 17","a":57},{"b":"d","i":"855926","t":"Los Angeles Youth Network Launches New Home For Foster & Homeless Youth","a":58},{"b":"d","i":"855910","t":"Why Republicans don't need to debate","a":59},{"b":"d","i":"855916","t":"Long-term results of RTOG 0236 confirm good primary tumor control, positive 5-year survival rates","a":60},{"b":"d","i":"855920","t":"Long-Term Results of RTOG 0236 Confirm Good Primary Tumor Control and Positive Five-Year Survival Rates for Lung ...","a":61},{"b":"c","i":"1813262","t":"Chromecast bulks up on content with support for Disney, Twitch, iHeartRadio","a":62},{"b":"d","i":"855898","t":"40 districts in UP declared drought-hit","a":63},{"b":"c","i":"1813253","t":"West Africans welcome U.S. effort to fight Ebola","a":64},{"b":"d","i":"855871","t":"REVA Presents Fantom Scaffold Program at TCT 2014 Conference","a":65},{"b":"d","i":"855876","t":"Australian shares set to rise on Wall St gains","a":66},{"b":"d","i":"855824","t":"Argentine Authorities Said to Reach Oil Bill Accord","a":67},{"b":"d","i":"855825","t":"Argentina Warns of Severe Measures for U.S. Envoy's Default Talk","a":68},{"b":"c","i":"1813229","t":"Pennsylvania Cop Shooter Hit Two Troopers and Missed One in 90 Seconds","a":69},{"b":"c","i":"1813224","t":"Driver alert: Bike buffer zone now the law","a":70},{"b":"d","i":"855775","t":"107.11 \u00a5\/$ (5 p.m.)","a":71},{"b":"d","i":"855786","t":"Nicklaus-designed Montreux set to host newly named Barracuda Championship","a":72},{"b":"f","i":"1067811","t":"Brewers Rip Bruisers As Heat On Home Violence Spreads To NFL Sponsors","a":73},{"b":"c","i":"1813208","t":"From Mad Men to Empowered Working Moms","a":74},{"b":"d","i":"855728","t":"Touch International Achieves AS9100 Aerospace Certification","a":75},{"b":"d","i":"855731","t":"Shanghai gold trading platform given surprise launch date","a":76},{"b":"f","i":"1067857","t":"The 404 Show 1,552: Don't bring Surge back, PS4 Nike Air Jordans have HDMI ports (podcast)","a":77},{"b":"d","i":"855703","t":"Fastly Secures $40 Million to Expand Global Content Delivery Network","a":78},{"b":"d","i":"855690","t":"Chinese President Xi arrives in India today","a":79},{"b":"e","i":"501962","t":"Walmart Told Customers a Fake ‘Sugar Tax’ Was Making Their Coke Cost More","a":80},{"b":"d","i":"855681","t":"Packaged Food Industry to Reach US$2.4 Trillion in Retail Sales in 2014","a":81},{"b":"d","i":"855682","t":"Mobility and Connectivity Challenge and Complement Broadcasting at IBC2014","a":82},{"b":"d","i":"855689","t":"National Credit Default Rates Increase Marginally in August 2014 According to the S&P\/Experian Consumer Credit Default ...","a":83},{"b":"d","i":"855659","t":"Silver Spring Showcases Networked Street Lights and Smart City Momentum at 2014 IES Street and Area Lighting Conference","a":84},{"b":"d","i":"855618","t":"TMC thanks people of Bengal for entrusting their faith on Mamata","a":85},{"b":"d","i":"855637","t":"Biodiversity informatics vital for sustainable growth: Prakash Javadekar","a":86},{"b":"e","i":"501923","t":"Obama: Ebola 'Spreading Faster and Exponentially'","a":87},{"b":"f","i":"1067667","t":"Brands Sound Off on the NFL's Brutal Episodes","a":88},{"b":"e","i":"501924","t":"Cotton: 'Pryor Refuses to Debate' Foreign Policy","a":89},{"b":"d","i":"855574","t":"Yokohama Tire Corporation Names National Non-Profit KaBOOM! as LPGA Charity Recipient","a":90},{"b":"d","i":"855577","t":"Frontier Capital Portfolio Companies Recognized For Growth","a":91},{"b":"e","i":"501896","t":"Black, White, Asian, Hispanic: The Disparities in Household Income","a":92},{"b":"e","i":"501907","t":"ScienceInsider","a":93},{"b":"e","i":"501908","t":"ScienceShot","a":94},{"b":"f","i":"1067697","t":"'Heartbroken' Family of Missing UVA Student Pleads for Help","a":95},{"b":"f","i":"1067642","t":"WWE RAW Viewership Down, WWE Stock Down, Chris Jericho Talking to Top TNA Tag Team","a":96},{"b":"e","i":"501876","t":"Whitney Houston's first live album to be released this November","a":97},{"b":"c","i":"1813078","t":"Ebola Epidemic 'Spiraling Out of Control,' Obama Says","a":98},{"b":"c","i":"1813072","t":"Map: Vintage Atlantic Wine Region gives New Jersey wine lovers a destination","a":99},{"b":"e","i":"501835","t":"Don Garber: Bruce Arena to receive 'major fine' over critical comments","a":100}]


"How to Gauge the Price of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!



        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      TIPS Lag Behind Conventional Treasuries Before CPI, Fed Report