English | Italian

"Ukraine: The Clash of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
SINOS DA RÚSSIA / Russian Bells - SUZDAL
Bélgica x Russia entrada em campo
Nuvem em forma de Cruz aparece em por do sol na Russia
Melhores momentos Brasil 3 x 1 Russia Mundial Feminino de Volei 04.10.2014
Life in St. Petersburg, Russia Жизнь в Санкт Петербург, Россия Vida em St. Petersburg, Russia ا
uma nuven em forma de cruz no ceu da russia
Continue »
Pop theme

John Cantlie,Republican Party,Ebola Virus,Fireworks Stafford,Burkina Faso,Ukraine gas,David Cameron,Andy Murray,Peshmerga,Marvel Comics

Related theme

cold war

Ukraine: The Clash of Partnerships | The Nation


russia ” em

2014-03-05 20:26:43

Russian soldiers outside a Ukranian border guard post in the Crimean town of Balaclava, March 1, 2014. (Reuters/Baz Ratner)

This article is a joint publication of TheNation.com and Foreign Policy In Focus.

The Cold War is history. For those growing up today, it is as distant in time as World War II was for those who came of age in the 1970s. In both cases, empires collapsed and maps were redrawn. Repugnant ideologies were laid bare and then laid to rest, though patches of nostalgia persist.

Surely the Cold War has been consigned to the textbooks as irrevocably as the Battle of the Bulge. The Berlin Wall is in pieces. The US president speaks of the abolition of nuclear weapons. The “common European home” from the Atlantic to the

Urals—a conceit embraced by such odd bedfellows as De Gaulle and Gorbachev—beckons on the horizon, with the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) in place and the European Union creeping ever eastward. Tensions inevitably crop up, but they’re nothing worth exchanging ICBMs over.

What was once confrontation has turned into joint efforts to address global challenges: stabilizing the world economy, negotiating nuclear agreements with Iran, ending the war in Syria. A long article in The New Yorkeron a multibillion-dollar nuclear fusion project being constructed in France reminds us that this quest for a sustainable replacement for fossil fuels began as a late Cold War agreement between Moscow and Washington. Impending environmental catastrophe is gradually uniting all sides in much the same way that Ronald Reagan once imagined that a Martian invasion would.

And then there’s Ukraine.

Just when you thought it was safe to get back into geopolitics, the Cold War has reared its ugly head once again. All your favorite characters have returned to the footlights—the iron-fisted Russian leader, the thundering American secretary of state, troops of multiple nations on alert and lots of cloak-and-dagger intrigue behind the scenes. And starring in the role of Prague 1968 is that new and untested actor: Crimea 2014. We can only hope that history is repeating itself as farce, not as a tragic tale told twice.

But there are some crucial differences in this restaging of the Cold War classic. The West has not been practicing containment of Russia so much as rollback of its influence by expanding NATO and the EU up to the country’s doorstep. And Moscow is not invoking some form of internationalism in support of ideological compatriots but nationalism pure and simple to safeguard its ethnic brethren. Moreover, this is a democratic age: Russian military intervention now comes with the Duma’s imprimatur. From the West, so far, has come much sound and fury, including the threat of economic sanctions and other penalties, but a military response remains off the table. There is still time to find a diplomatic solution that can preserve Ukrainian sovereignty, address the concerns of Russians on both sides of the border and revive that old vision of a common European home that treats Russia as a member, not a mobster.

When people speak of “Russia’s doorstep,” they mean Ukraine. No one aspires to be a doorstep, because that’s what people walk on with their muddy boots. As Timothy Snyder has detailed in his book Bloodlands, Ukraine has suffered incalculable losses because of its location, first as a locus of potential resistance to Soviet control and then as a battleground during World War II. War pushed the country’s boundaries westward to incorporate what had once been parts of Poland. Changing the map only further emphasized Ukraine’s centrality to the fate of Europe, particularly after the disintegration of the Soviet Union in 1991. The western sections have leaned Europe-ward, while large numbers of Russian speakers in the east feel some measure of allegiance to Moscow.

It’s not just language that threatens to divide Ukraine like the poor baby in the parable about King Solomon. It’s also a question of which collective entity to huddle in for shelter. Ukraine joined Russia and Belarus to create the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) in December 1991 as the Soviet Union fell to pieces around them. But Ukraine was also the first CIS member to join NATO’s Partnership for Peace program in 1994. Fifteen years later, Ukraine signed up for the European Union’s Eastern Partnership. Russia has not been happy about either of these partnerships. Moscow put together its own partnership, the Eurasian Economic Community, more than a dozen years ago, but Ukraine is only an observer.

A clash of partnerships is now threatening to break out on the peninsula of Crimea. This semi-autonomous region is the only part of Ukraine with a majority of Russian speakers, and it also hosts Russia’s Black Sea Fleet. In Crimea’s 2010 parliamentary elections, Viktor Yanukovych’s Russophone Party of Regions scored a huge victory. But a large population of Crimean Tatars—twelve to fifteen percent of the two million people who live on the peninsula—has rallied in support of the new government in Kiev. The sympathies of Crimeans are clearly divided.

And now, it seems, Crimea itself is divided. Armed men stormed the Crimean parliament last week and forced the appointment of Sergei Aksyonov as the new prime minister of the peninsula. Aksyonov immediately appealed to Russia for assistance and set a date for a referendum on Crimean independence. Russian troops have spread throughout the peninsula to secure both civilian and military installations. Russian guards are posted outside Ukrainian military bases. The peninsula is divided between pro-Russian and pro-Ukrainian forces, with Aksyonov already declaring a new Crimean army that he insists Ukrainian soldiers must join. Russian troops conducting exercises at the border recently returned home, and Vladimir Putin has said that his country has no intention of swallowing Crimea. Indeed, absorption might not be his goal, for even the tastiest morsels have a habit of sticking in the throat.

Crimea is not the only challenge to Ukraine’s unity. Kharkiv, located a scant forty kilometers from the border with Russia, is the country’s second-largest city. Earlier in the week, a group of Cossacks seized control of the city hall and hoisted a Russian flag. But the new Ukrainian authorities eventually re-established control. Places like Crimea and Kharkiv could swing either way in their sympathies. Russian troops plus separatist sentiment could produce an Abkhazian or Transnistrian scenario: breakaway provinces recognized by only a handful of countries around the world. Only compromise—a free-and-fair referendum, the preservation of minority rights, a moratorium on NATO expansion—can prevent fracture.

The continuing crisis in Ukraine has generated its share of Cold War–style inanities. One favorite trope of that period was the “mote in your eye” accusation. Secretary of State John Kerry, who apparently only lives in the present, recently intoned that “you just don’t invade another country on phony pretexts in order to assert your interests.” Then there’s the “if they only had nukes” argument. John Mearsheimer thinks Ukraine shouldn’t have given up its nuclear arsenal back in 1994 because those weapons would have made Russia think twice about sending troops into Crimea. Will the MAD scientists never learn? The situation in Ukraine is bad enough without adding WMD to the mix, whether in the form of deliberate attack, accidental use or loose nukes.

But the chief inanity is the one that has governed Western policy since 1991—that there would be no costs to the expansion of NATO and the European Union. Leaders in Washington and Brussels have been repeatedly warned by those with just a passing familiarity with Russian history and culture that encroachment in Moscow’s sphere of influence—its “near abroad”—is tantamount to poking the bear. Yes, it’s true that both institutions are responding to genuine interests “on the ground.” But the stakes here are very high. It’s not just about “losing Ukraine.” It would be an even greater catastrophe to “lose Russia.” And here I mean not the Cold War game of winning and losing but the more universal struggle between a liberating order and a debilitating chaos.

Please support our journalism. Get a digital subscription for just $9.50!

Indeed, with the rise of Putin and the freeze that has settled over freedom of expression and assembly, Russia is already being lost by degrees. It can’t be allowed to drift further into the politics of reaction. But the traditional approach to “saving Russia” has been a dual strategy of rolling back its influence externally and funding democracy initiatives within the country. However much I would love to see Ukraine in the European Union one day and however much I support civil society initiatives inside Russia, enthusiasts for these projects must recognize that they strengthen the hands of those who argue the West is only interested in neutering Mother Russia. Backlash is almost inevitable.

Policymakers in Washington and Brussels should take a much longer view. Instead of concentrating on “partnerships” that put Russia beyond the pale, they have to revive a much more encompassing vision of European security. As long as we continue to shave away at the habitat where the bear lives, it will swipe at its encroachers and defend its ground. “Some days you’ll eat the bear,” goes the old Joan Armatrading song, while “some days the bear will eat you.”

It might seem ridiculous to talk about grand partnerships with Russia at the very moment when the international community wants to put Putin in the penalty box. But Russia is much bigger than just Vladimir Putin, despite the man’s penchant for self-aggrandizement. Making a place at the table for this vast country is a chief challenge for the twenty-first century. So, even as we condemn the introduction of Russian troops in Crimea and decry the narrowing of democratic freedoms in Moscow, we have to remember that the Cold War is over, it should never return and both sides must act that way.

Read Next: The Editors urge realism and common sense on Ukraine.

View Original Article: thenation.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source thenation.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Ukraine: The Clash of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"a","i":"1362848","t":"A 'hard,' deadly day for space tourism | National News - WLWT Home","a":1},{"b":"b","i":"1299569","t":"VIDEO: Pearl S. Buck International hosts naturalization ceremonies for 48 new American citizens","a":2},{"b":"a","i":"1362830","t":"Maine nurse won't submit to Ebola quarantine, lawyer says","a":3},{"b":"b","i":"1299542","t":"Strong Q3 show from Bakkafrost","a":4},{"b":"b","i":"1299533","t":"SUSE Cranks Enterprise Linux to 12","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1299537","t":"Massachusetts, New Hampshire election coverage","a":6},{"b":"b","i":"1299518","t":"NMSU FOOTBALL: Five keys to beat the Bobcats","a":7},{"b":"a","i":"1362758","t":"Key weighs sending Kiwi medics to help with Ebola crisis","a":8},{"b":"a","i":"1362739","t":"Montco officials monitoring West Africa travelers for Ebola","a":9},{"b":"c","i":"1897244","t":"The Coming November Wars","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1362727","t":"PM Narendra Modi greets Karnataka on state formation day","a":11},{"b":"f","i":"1175097","t":"Frights and sights 2014 Halloween parties","a":12},{"b":"f","i":"1175116","t":"Taco Bell unveils mobile app for ordering","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1299463","t":"U.S. Secretary of Commerce Penny Pritzker Announces Next Phase of Investing in Manufacturing Communities Partnership Initiative","a":14},{"b":"a","i":"1362715","t":"Mexico frees jailed U.S. Marine reservist | National News - WGAL Home","a":15},{"b":"a","i":"1362719","t":"Family 'overjoyed' U.S. Marine reservist freed from Mexican prison","a":16},{"b":"b","i":"1299500","t":"Development picks up as region's industrial market gets even hotter\r\nReal Estate","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1299502","t":"The Tannery sold to Madison-based real estate firm","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1299508","t":"Nik Wallenda Is Ready for His Chicago Tightrope Walk","a":19},{"b":"b","i":"1299446","t":"Connecticut Junk Hunters Find Human Skulls In Deceased Man\u2019s Home","a":20},{"b":"b","i":"1299449","t":"The Institutes for the Achievement of Human Potential Launches The Pathway to Wellness: A New Online Community for Parents of Children with Special Needs","a":21},{"b":"a","i":"1362674","t":"U.S. Census Bureau Daily Feature for November 1","a":22},{"b":"a","i":"1362676","t":"These Gun Control Ads Will Actually Be The Scariest Thing You See Today","a":23},{"b":"b","i":"1299422","t":"Resolute Forest Products Reports Preliminary Third Quarter 2014 Results","a":24},{"b":"f","i":"1175052","t":"Hornets expect physical contest","a":25},{"b":"f","i":"1175056","t":"Today in History","a":26},{"b":"d","i":"977834","t":"Panorama Festival 2014","a":27},{"b":"f","i":"1175087","t":"Space Tourism Isn't Worth Dying For","a":28},{"b":"c","i":"1897200","t":"Shep Smith to PA Police Officials: Don\u2019t You Kind of Wish Eric Frein Had Resisted?","a":29},{"b":"b","i":"1299416","t":"Navarro, Muguruza into WTA Sofia semis","a":30},{"b":"f","i":"1175061","t":"Green Dream, or Crimson Title: Game Could Decide Ivy Crown","a":31},{"b":"f","i":"1175063","t":"Sergey Kovalev Deerfield Beach Media Workout Quotes","a":32},{"b":"b","i":"1299393","t":"Green Market opens in Royal Palm Beach","a":33},{"b":"f","i":"1175064","t":"LIVE! Bangalore is officially Bengaluru from today","a":34},{"b":"f","i":"1175092","t":"Virgin Galactic's commercial spacecraft crashes, kills co-pilot","a":35},{"b":"e","i":"535356","t":"Leaked FCC Report Details Weak \"Hybrid\" Plans For Net Neutrality","a":36},{"b":"b","i":"1299357","t":"U.S. Deputy Commerce Secretary Bruce Andrews Delivers Closing Remarks at First-Ever Investing In Manufacturing Communities Partnership Summit","a":37},{"b":"b","i":"1299363","t":"San Diego Economic Indicators Point Up","a":38},{"b":"a","i":"1362569","t":"The Inquirer and Mirror","a":39},{"b":"a","i":"1362571","t":"Huawei to Invest $500 Million into Ontario over next 5 years","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1299366","t":"Fox elected as new co-leader","a":41},{"b":"f","i":"1175010","t":"Santa Visiting VHS for Pet Pictures this Weekend","a":42},{"b":"b","i":"1299368","t":"Narendra Modi should have gone to pay tribute to Indira Gandhi: ND Tiwari","a":43},{"b":"f","i":"1174954","t":"Green Dream, or Crimson Title: Game Could Decide Ivy Crown","a":44},{"b":"f","i":"1174958","t":"Section 8 transfer not so smooth","a":45},{"b":"b","i":"1299323","t":"China's Orient Paper Temporarily Suspends Production Due to Government Mandate","a":46},{"b":"b","i":"1299327","t":"Fireworks blaze search to resume","a":47},{"b":"a","i":"1362556","t":"Mystery Witness at the Jodi Arias Trial","a":48},{"b":"b","i":"1299303","t":"Orchids Paper Products Posts Record Third Quarter 2014 Results on Improved Sales","a":49},{"b":"b","i":"1299295","t":"Theater Group Presents 'Dearly Departed'","a":50},{"b":"a","i":"1362476","t":"Nita Ambani to celebrate birthday in Modi\u2019s Varanasi","a":51},{"b":"a","i":"1362489","t":"Will broad family tax relief equal votes? - Revelstoke Times Review","a":52},{"b":"b","i":"1299277","t":"Castle Hills resident turns home into haunted castle","a":53},{"b":"b","i":"1299275","t":"November 1, 2014","a":54},{"b":"b","i":"1299246","t":"Prices Soar For Some Generic Drugs — Why?","a":55},{"b":"b","i":"1299251","t":"Today's Clickers","a":56},{"b":"a","i":"1362404","t":"Theater Group Presents 'Dearly Departed'","a":57},{"b":"a","i":"1362407","t":"Featured Brokers","a":58},{"b":"f","i":"1175030","t":"OPINION: Halloween is your chance to act like a kid again","a":59},{"b":"b","i":"1299226","t":"GBH Announces Selection to INSIDE Public Accounting's Best of the Best Firms List for 2014","a":60},{"b":"a","i":"1362379","t":"WWE Comments on Current Lawsuits, Says Billy Jack Haynes Claims Are Without Merit","a":61},{"b":"b","i":"1299238","t":"Tabbug Bridge opens today","a":62},{"b":"b","i":"1299181","t":"Things to watch","a":63},{"b":"c","i":"1897069","t":"Harry Reid Pleads to Democrat Supporters: 'I'm Begging You'","a":64},{"b":"b","i":"1299171","t":"Statement by NSC Spokesperson Bernadette Meehan on Deputy National Security Advisor for Strategic Communications Benjamin Rhodes\u2019 Meeting with Yezidi Leaders | The White House","a":65},{"b":"f","i":"1174796","t":"Kim Kardashian Dresses North in Skunk Costume; See How the Today Show Celebrated Halloween: Top 5 Stories","a":66},{"b":"f","i":"1174798","t":"History: Nov. 1, 2014","a":67},{"b":"c","i":"1897043","t":"stltoday.com","a":68},{"b":"f","i":"1174800","t":"Shep Smith to PA Police Officials: Don't You Kind of Wish Eric Frein Had Resisted?","a":69},{"b":"a","i":"1362348","t":"MISSING VULNERABLE ADULT ALERT: 93-year-old man with dementia missing","a":70},{"b":"a","i":"1362326","t":"Ann Romney Plans Loudoun Stop To Support GOP Ticket","a":71},{"b":"a","i":"1362327","t":"Armed Robber Hits CountrySide Bank","a":72},{"b":"f","i":"1174892","t":"Halloween in Tweets: The Pros get spooky","a":73},{"b":"a","i":"1362309","t":"Spaceship Explodes: One Dead After Virgin Galactic Craft Goes Down Mid-flight","a":74},{"b":"a","i":"1362311","t":"Swimming & Diving","a":75},{"b":"a","i":"1362321","t":"Fireworks blaze search to resume","a":76},{"b":"c","i":"1897024","t":"Bridgeport\u2019s Black Rock Discovers \u2018Cool\u2019 Side","a":77},{"b":"f","i":"1174805","t":"'Gades to host Santa Barbara in opener today","a":78},{"b":"f","i":"1174807","t":"FedEx Freight Workers In New Jersey Vote To Join Teamsters Local 701","a":79},{"b":"f","i":"1174921","t":"Eric Frein: What we learned today about his manhunt and capture","a":80},{"b":"e","i":"535317","t":"Is a Santa Claus Rally Ahead, or Yet Another Bust?","a":81},{"b":"a","i":"1362252","t":"Top-rated reviews of the week (pictures)","a":82},{"b":"f","i":"1174690","t":"Roundabout Nov. 1","a":83},{"b":"f","i":"1174698","t":"Trending Halloween Buzz","a":84},{"b":"a","i":"1362231","t":"Jose ‘happy where we are’","a":85},{"b":"c","i":"1896977","t":"Deadly day for space tourism -- but future 'rests' on such days, official says","a":86},{"b":"a","i":"1362223","t":"Human Longevity, Inc. Hires Industry Experts Barry Merriman, Ph.D., and Paul Mola, M.S. to Lead New Global Solutions Initiative","a":87},{"b":"a","i":"1362198","t":"Canyon set for winning start over flights","a":88},{"b":"a","i":"1362216","t":"WAYNE Water Systems Awards This Old House Fans with Sump Pumps in \u201cThis Old House Great TOH Giveaway Sweepstakes\u201d","a":89},{"b":"d","i":"977715","t":"Read the messages of thanks from the wives of three slain Mounties","a":90},{"b":"c","i":"1896958","t":"Starbucks Franken Frappuccino: $3 after 2 p.m.","a":91},{"b":"a","i":"1362157","t":"Coalition braced for protests over water charges","a":92},{"b":"a","i":"1362159","t":"Thousands expected to attend anti-water charge protests in Cork city and county","a":93},{"b":"c","i":"1896922","t":"Bad News for Amazon: Google Play Movies and TV Are Now on Roku","a":94},{"b":"c","i":"1896921","t":"Virgin Galactic vows to continue space program after 'serious anomaly'","a":95},{"b":"c","i":"1896910","t":"stltoday.com","a":96},{"b":"f","i":"1174668","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":97},{"b":"d","i":"977542","t":"Truth is hard but residential school reconciliation harder: Murray Sinclair","a":98},{"b":"d","i":"977510","t":"Live: Albany's Anzac centenary commemorations","a":99},{"b":"d","i":"977518","t":""Northmen - A Viking Saga" Acquired for Distribution and Premium Pay TV Deal with Starz","a":100}]

      100

      A 'hard,' deadly day for space tourism | National News - WLWT Home