English | Italian

"Why Iran Doesn’t..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
Rouhani: Iran hopes to reach mutually acceptable agreement.
John Kerry: US has "fervent hope" to reach deal with Iran in weeks
Iran Pres: We can reach nuclear deal
Iran Pres: We can reach nuclear deal
Iran Pres: We can reach nuclear deal
Is an Iran Nuclear Deal Within Reach Dissecting the Latest Talks over a Manufactured Crisis
Continue »
Pop theme

Bibeau,Europe budget,Elizabeth II,Ebola Virus,Carswell,Marysville,Dilma Rousseff,Jeffrey Fowle,Taylor Swift,Zellweger

Related theme

Why Iran Doesn’t Trust the International Community


iran understanding reach

2014-04-21 23:26:48

Iran has a fraught relationship with international institutions dating back at least to the Iran-Iraq War of the 1980s. (Photo: Sebastià Giralt / Flickr)

Reza Nasri, an international lawyer and academic, is a Shelby Davis scholar in international law at the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (HEI) in Geneva. His work examines the role of the United Nations Security Council in the Iranian nuclear enrichment program, the legality of extraterritorial and unilateral sanctions, the lawfulness of attacking nuclear facilities under laws of armed conflict, cyber-attacks as a use of force, and the legal effects of threatening a party during the course of negotiations.

In this exclusive interview, he shares his thoughts and ideas about Iran’s relationship with international organizations.

Jahandad Memarian: Iran has always been cynical

    No results related

    Add now

toward international organizations’ intentions. For example, Iran has refused requests by the United Nations (UN) Special Rapporteur, Ahmed Shaheed, to assess that country’s human rights status first-hand. In fact, Tehran characterizes the appointment of a UN special rapporteur on Iran as a politically motivated decision. Iranian officials frequently insist that Shaheed’s reports are based on “a biased approach” that relies on unconfirmed reports and do not “merit public trust or confidence.” What explains the Iranian reaction to this issue?

Reza Nasri:Iran’s cynicism is not unfounded. There is a long history of friction and mistrust between Iran and some of the major international organizations that dates back to the Iran-Iraq war in the 1980s. For example, many influential people within the Iranian political establishment, as well as in the general public, vividly remember how the United Nations stayed indifferent to Saddam Hussein’s invasion and occupation of Iranian territory. Many also remember how, despite numerous pleas from Iran, all international mechanisms were deliberately put in standby mode as the Iraqi dictator dropped over 360 chemical bombs on Iranian military and civilian targets, causing over 100,000 casualties. So there is indeed a deep-rooted mistrust. And these organizations’ recent treatment of Iran over its nuclear program has only exasperated it.

Take the case of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), for example. We all know that the IAEA is an important international organization, with a very sensitive monitoring task. It should in principle conduct its operations impartially, apolitically, and indiscriminately, in accordance with precise standards and in perfect compliance with its legal mandate. However, looking at its record with Iran since 2002, any fair observer would attest to how unjustly and subjectively it has acted toward the country. In fact, in many instances—mainly because of Western pressure—the IAEA’s conduct has been outright biased and unlawful.

Not only did the IAEA blatantly exceed its mandate vis-à-vis Iran during the process of inspections (namely by requesting to inspect facilities that fall outside its purview), but it went so far as to draft its reports based on dubious “information” provided by intelligence agencies and countries rival to Iran. Specifically, it used material from Israel, which is neither a member of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), nor—as anyone would concede—too enthusiastic about seeing the Iranian dossier resolved peacefully. Of course, the IAEA did not have the right to use these so-called “evidences” to incriminate Iran; but it did so anyway, at Iran’s great expense.

Likewise, the IAEA controversially transferred Iran’s file from the IAEA Board of Governors to the UN Security Council—an extraordinary escalatory measure that cost the Iranian economy billions of dollars. That also occurred in blatant violation of all applicable laws, as most serious experts and scholars have since demonstrated.

Or take a look at how the Security Council—an institution that must first and foremost encourage and facilitate multilateral diplomacy—set aside all its conflict-resolution mechanisms in the case of Iran to opt instead for a disproportionate and aggressive approach that solely revolved around “sanctions.” In fact, the Security Council directly jumped to its Chapter VII measures without establishing and clearly demonstrating how Iran’s nuclear program constituted a “threat to international peace and security,” as international law requires.

So in this context, it is not surprising that Iranian decision makers—and not just the hardliners, but also the moderate technocrats within the foreign policy establishment—are quite hesitant about allowing yet another institution to openly meddle in Iranian affairs. After all, they’d ask, if a complex and sophisticated “technical” organization such as the IAEA can so easily be derailed from its mandate and be used by political foes to undermine Iran’s interests, what guarantees do we have that a single individual—namely the UN Human Rights Council’s Special Rapporteur—would act independently? How could we trust that the Special Rapporteur’s real agenda is not in fact to recommend Iran’s referral back to the Security Council—this time on human rights grounds—once we’ve finally settled the nuclear file?

In my opinion, these are legitimate questions that need to be addressed. In fact, I believe that world powers must genuinely come to the realization that misusing international organizations as political tools does indeed have long-term consequences, namely by compromising  the credibility and function of the “international system” as a whole. If they really want Iran or other countries to fully partake in this system for the sake of human rights, or for other considerations, they must sincerely engage in its reform or revise their own practice.

Reza Nasri

Jahandad Memarian: Iran has behaved similarly toward international media outlets, non-governmental organizations, and independent think thanks. How do you explain Iran’s cynical attitude?

Reza Nasri:From Iran’s perspective, these organizations have also played a central role in fuelling and sustaining the nuclear “crisis”—which some commentators have rightly dubbed a “manufactured crisis.” Some of them have systematically tainted Iran’s image in the media and actively promoted a narrative that prescribes war and sanctions as the only means to deal with the country. In fact, Iranophobia has become a real industry in the United States in the past few years. Millions of dollars in public and private funds are allocated each year to boost these organizations, whose sole purpose is to single out Iran and portray it as a threat to international security.

You may find it interesting to know that South Korea—not North Korea, but South Korea!—had been found by the IAEA in 2004 to have enriched uranium to weapons-grade levels and to have pursued a secretive weapons program in flagrant violation of its international obligations. This was revealed in 2004—two years after the Iranian nuclear “crisis” began. But public opinion never heard of it. None of these organizations talked of South Korea as a rogue state. None of them systematically seized the media to portray South Korea as a nuclear threat. None of them organized panel after panel in Washington, DC to decry South Korea’s blow to the non-proliferation regime. None of these think tanks even mentioned the fact that South Korea’s breach of its nuclear obligations had by far surpassed Iran’s—a country that in fact was never found to have had a weapons program.

So, there is indeed an undeniable malicious intention vis-à-vis Iran, which is mainly fuelled by Iran’s geopolitical foes in the region that seek the country’s isolation. Against this background, it is understandable that Iran doesn’t view these institutions very positively either. In fact, their project runs directly against Iran’s aspirations to renew its ties with Western countries.

Jahandad Memarian: In Washington, some believe that the rhetoric of threat has a strong impact on Iran and can be used as an effective tool in negotiations. They believe that the hawks’ aggressive policies can create an effective good cop/bad cop dynamic that enhances Obama’s diplomacy. Do you believe that such threats can force Iran eventually to succumb to the international community’s demands?

Reza Nasri:To address your question and illustrate the effects of threats in international relations, allow me a small detour into the current Ukrainian crisis. We often hear these days from U.S. and European officials that the Crimean referendum of independence was “illegal” under international law because it took place under the coercive presence and intimidation of Russian forces. Those who invoke this argument have a valid point. In fact, their point relies on a universally recognized legal principle, which posits that “coercion nullifies true consent.” In simple terms, that means that any “agreement” that comes out of duress, threats, and intimidation has no legal value and hence is voidable. The provisions of the UN Charter, the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, and customary international law—as well as the International Court of Justice—all support this position.

Now let’s come back to the Iranian situation: While Iran is sitting across the table negotiating over its nuclear program with representatives of the P5+1, the U.S. Congress and other Western officials still talk with impunity of coercing the country into more concessions with more sanctions and more “credible” threats of military force, which they unabashedly tag as an immovable “option on the table.”

So one should ask, why would the above legal principle (the prohibition of threats and duress) apply to the Crimean referendum but not to the Iran-P5+1 negotiation process? Why would the act of coercion, threat, and duress nullify the results of a popular referendum in one case but “consolidate” the outcome of a negotiation process in another?

The truth is that threats and coercion—whether military or economic—are incompatible with fundamental legal principles and the notion of good faith, especially in times of negotiations. Threatening a negotiating partner with more pressure, more sanctions, and more insecurity is not only contrary to core principles of law and morality, but it also has practical legal ramifications that could emerge in the long-term.

Indeed, proponents of this approach should bear in mind that even if Iran does cave in to the illegal threats of force and sanctions—and if it actually concedes to a nuclear agreement procured under duress by the Congress—it could very well move to nullify that agreement at later date in perfect compliance with international law. In fact, as I’ve written elsewhere, what the U.S. Congress and its radicals seem to view today as valuable “leverage” in the ongoing negotiations with Iran could very well turn into the Achilles’ heel of any future arrangement.

So, in order to reinforce the legal position of its own administration, the U.S. Congress should seriously abstain from adopting any measure that could be construed by Iran as coercion, threat, or intimidation. In other words, congressional leaders should understand that by ratcheting up the rhetoric or by adopting or threatening to adopt more sanctions against a party to the negotiations—whether in the name of non-proliferation or under the guise of fighting terrorism—they are just weakening the legal position of their own government and its allies and jeopardizing the sustainability of any eventual agreement. If their intention is genuinely to reach an understanding with Iran, then they should just let the negotiations proceed in a calm and tension-free environment.

View Original Article: fpif.org
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source fpif.org.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Why Iran Doesn’t..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"d","i":"962092","t":"Jaskin comes through with game deciding goal against Hawks","a":1},{"b":"d","i":"962061","t":"UFC 179 in Tweets: Pros react to Jose Aldo vs. Chad Mendes, Phil Davis vs. Glover Teixeira","a":2},{"b":"d","i":"962064","t":"Poll: Should Nigel Farage be included in more than one TV debate?","a":3},{"b":"d","i":"962068","t":"Osborne seeks bidders for Eurostar","a":4},{"b":"d","i":"962070","t":"Gaming N ews","a":5},{"b":"a","i":"1338125","t":"Alcohol costing NHS \u00a3106m a year in the Black Country and Staffordshire","a":6},{"b":"a","i":"1338132","t":"Banks pay \u00a31.5bn over 'rate swaps'","a":7},{"b":"a","i":"1338134","t":"New report wake-up call for dairy export sector","a":8},{"b":"d","i":"962023","t":"Five-minute blitz wins series for United States","a":9},{"b":"d","i":"962025","t":"Packers, Saints battle in season-defining matchup","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1338117","t":"Wolves offer fans value at all costs","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1276255","t":"Ukraine gears up for vote today ","a":12},{"b":"b","i":"1276256","t":"Qatar- Documentary on forced disappearances in Sri Lanka to be shown today ","a":13},{"b":"a","i":"1338101","t":"Najib to attend 10TH WIEF in Dubai \u2013 Bernama - Yahoo News Malaysia","a":14},{"b":"d","i":"962015","t":"LunaDress Now Release Its Designer Inspired Fashion Wedding Dresses For Customers Dwelling In The UK","a":15},{"b":"b","i":"1276243","t":"BizTimes accepts nominations for Health Care Heroes","a":16},{"b":"b","i":"1276234","t":"Man's body found at bottom of stairwell","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1276237","t":"RELATED ARTICLES:","a":18},{"b":"d","i":"962007","t":"MQM\u2019s black day despite Khursheed\u2019s apology","a":19},{"b":"d","i":"962013","t":"Iran hangs Reyhaneh Jabbari despite campaign","a":20},{"b":"g","i":"36925","t":"Global Fraud Detection and Prevention market to grow at a CAGR of 16.4 percent by 2018","a":21},{"b":"d","i":"962002","t":"Macri assures he will confront a Kirchnerite candidate in second round of 2015","a":22},{"b":"d","i":"962004","t":"Brazil's election too close to call on eve of runoff","a":23},{"b":"d","i":"962005","t":"US FDA issues emergency authorization for two new Ebola tests","a":24},{"b":"a","i":"1338046","t":"Brazil run-off vote today ","a":25},{"b":"c","i":"1885808","t":"Psych patients pack emergency rooms","a":26},{"b":"a","i":"1338051","t":"Minister of Foreign Affairs Makes Telephone Call with Egyptian Foreign Minister ","a":27},{"b":"e","i":"530412","t":"Brazilians Vote for Leader as Polls Show Nation Divided","a":28},{"b":"e","i":"530414","t":"Ukraine Votes in Wartime Ballot Set to Back Pro-EU Forces","a":29},{"b":"c","i":"1885805","t":"Veteran tech entrepreneur bridges academic, business worlds","a":30},{"b":"a","i":"1338011","t":"Dwelling consents growth slowing","a":31},{"b":"b","i":"1276153","t":"Parental anxiety breeding anxious kids","a":32},{"b":"a","i":"1337995","t":"Hiring Intentions Remain Steady","a":33},{"b":"a","i":"1337985","t":"Family fun guaranteed at this year's Alstonville Show","a":34},{"b":"c","i":"1885741","t":"Body of missing man, 22, located in wooded area","a":35},{"b":"b","i":"1276103","t":"Port problems slow flow of goods before holidays; container ships idle off Los Angeles","a":36},{"b":"a","i":"1337948","t":"Apple Pay's next move could be phone-to-phone payments","a":37},{"b":"c","i":"1885724","t":"Ebola Today: Nurse Who Tests Negative for Ebola Speaks Out on Treatment","a":38},{"b":"b","i":"1276054","t":"Small Island Nations Sound Climate Alarm at UN","a":39},{"b":"b","i":"1276065","t":"Vancive and Aspen Medical partner to distribute absorbent wound dressing products in the UK, Ireland","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1276028","t":"Action needed on cycling safety","a":41},{"b":"d","i":"961983","t":"Hong Kong's fourth annual SlutWalk stands against sexual violence","a":42},{"b":"f","i":"1159343","t":"Spring Has Sprung Show","a":43},{"b":"e","i":"530400","t":"Note To The Skeptics: The World Will Change For Self-Driving Cars","a":44},{"b":"a","i":"1337882","t":"Inflation falls to five-year low","a":45},{"b":"a","i":"1337885","t":"Seymour appointment green light for failing charter schools","a":46},{"b":"a","i":"1337891","t":"PM Modi to meet BJP MPs, allies over high tea at 7RCR today","a":47},{"b":"f","i":"1159375","t":"Neil Cavuto Fondly Remembers Terry Keenan","a":48},{"b":"a","i":"1337837","t":"Maddie Myers Doubles, Leads DU Pioneers Over Missouri State And Kansas","a":49},{"b":"a","i":"1337808","t":"Fashion designer Oscar de la Renta dies at 82","a":50},{"b":"a","i":"1337822","t":"History: Oct. 26, 2014","a":51},{"b":"b","i":"1275965","t":"Hands across the water: Kilmarnock's Irish links are forged for battle with Celtic","a":52},{"b":"b","i":"1275942","t":"Elderly woman critical in Dunedin accident","a":53},{"b":"a","i":"1337786","t":"OS X Yosemite uptake climbs to 13% in first week","a":54},{"b":"a","i":"1337793","t":"AdaCore Development Environment Selected for New Spanish Satellite Project","a":55},{"b":"a","i":"1337760","t":"Nevada Man Attacks 7 People With a Hammer","a":56},{"b":"a","i":"1337764","t":"Drive sober or get pulled over in Burlingame","a":57},{"b":"a","i":"1337768","t":"Grand Traverse 911 Open House Showcases Dispatch To Public","a":58},{"b":"b","i":"1275925","t":"Thousands of health workers strike over pay - including midwives for first time in history","a":59},{"b":"b","i":"1275924","t":"Manohar Lal Khattar to take oath as Haryana CM today, Modi likely to attend the ceremony","a":60},{"b":"b","i":"1275907","t":"Announcing @SOASoftwareInc to Exhibit at @CloudExpo [#Cloud #API]","a":61},{"b":"c","i":"1885565","t":"No. 15 Arizona beats Washington State 59-37","a":62},{"b":"c","i":"1885566","t":"No. 15 Arizona beats Washington State 59-37","a":63},{"b":"a","i":"1337751","t":"Myer relaunches brand as Clemenger BBDO Melbourne devises ‘find wonderful’ campaign","a":64},{"b":"c","i":"1885556","t":"Brazilians Vote for Leader as Polls Show Nation Divided","a":65},{"b":"c","i":"1885528","t":"Hillary: "Business Does Not Create Jobs", Washington Does","a":66},{"b":"e","i":"530377","t":"NYC Ebola Patient\u2019s Fiancee to Leave for Home Quarantine","a":67},{"b":"d","i":"961777","t":"Counting every drop: Los Angeles-area company helps Peninsula customers save water","a":68},{"b":"b","i":"1275774","t":"HP Broadens Moonshot Portfolio to New Applications for Increased Efficiency and Lower Cost","a":69},{"b":"d","i":"961761","t":"Irish artist suffers serious injuries in Limerick road crash","a":70},{"b":"b","i":"1275749","t":"It's okay to not be perfect: Huma Qureshi","a":71},{"b":"a","i":"1337589","t":"ROAR for America","a":72},{"b":"d","i":"961717","t":"Camels snapped enjoying the sun - on a Hampshire beach!","a":73},{"b":"a","i":"1337660","t":"UFC 179 results: Wilson Reis finishes Scott Jorgensen in first round","a":74},{"b":"a","i":"1337661","t":"Brazil To Elect President Amid Corruption Claim - Yahoo News UK","a":75},{"b":"a","i":"1337662","t":"Merry Murray | The Sunday Times","a":76},{"b":"a","i":"1337669","t":"I love edgy style \u2014 Utee Rone","a":77},{"b":"d","i":"961847","t":"Biden denounces 'cockamamie' Republican values at Vernon Hills rally","a":78},{"b":"a","i":"1337550","t":"\u2018Jom Heboh\u2019 celebrity auction today - Yahoo News Malaysia","a":79},{"b":"a","i":"1337551","t":"SA Pets Alive! celebrates opening of adoption center","a":80},{"b":"d","i":"961672","t":"Comment: Politics can't hold enterprise to ransom","a":81},{"b":"b","i":"1275789","t":"Rougaroo Festival draws crowds for a cause","a":82},{"b":"b","i":"1275675","t":"Sexual boosting oil seized with booze pedlar","a":83},{"b":"b","i":"1275791","t":"Lieberman Software Privilege Management Platform Now Includes SSH Key Management","a":84},{"b":"f","i":"1159087","t":"Jack Bruce, bassist of 60's band Cream, dies at 71","a":85},{"b":"c","i":"1885295","t":"Illinois Joins NY, NJ With Ebola Risk-Flier Quarantines","a":86},{"b":"f","i":"1159130","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":87},{"b":"e","i":"530329","t":"Premier Analysis: Hammers and Saints flying high as Man City and Liverpool stutter","a":88},{"b":"d","i":"961549","t":"Brand SRK now a trade mark","a":89},{"b":"d","i":"961568","t":"Government clears defence projects worth Rs 80,000 crores","a":90},{"b":"b","i":"1275600","t":"Betsy-Tacy Society Dedicates a Hitching Block","a":91},{"b":"d","i":"961529","t":"Activist Leaflets From South Korea Threaten Fragile Truce With North Korea","a":92},{"b":"d","i":"961525","t":"Pikmin Shorts Coming to the 3DS","a":93},{"b":"d","i":"961518","t":"Final Fantasy 14 Getting Flying Mounts, Personal Airships and More","a":94},{"b":"e","i":"530323","t":"Apple Cores Are a Myth","a":95},{"b":"d","i":"961465","t":"SHCI weakens further; SZCI up 0.5%","a":96},{"b":"d","i":"961447","t":"Defending champ Hend pulls clear with 67","a":97},{"b":"d","i":"961402","t":"CTA bomb screening is a waste","a":98},{"b":"d","i":"961370","t":"Top 10 city cars: a gift to urbanites from the god of small things","a":99},{"b":"b","i":"1275552","t":"Irish artist John Shinnors injured in Limerick road accident","a":100}]

      100

      Jaskin comes through with game deciding goal against Hawks