English | Italian

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
no related videos
Pop theme

Joko Widodo,Ebola vaccine,Bharatiya Janata Party,Oscar Pistorius,Rick Scott,Dilma Rousseff,Peyton Manning,Jeffrey Fowle,Gough Whitlam,Cloud

Related theme

lesotho percent

A Highly Dubious Measure of Innovation

2014-07-30 09:56:44

When you think “innovation,” do Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and Sweden come to mind? No? Well, those countries are at the top of the annual Global Innovation Index, released last Friday.

In case you hadn’t noticed, “innovation” has become quite the buzzword. It attracts attention, particularly in business circles. However, there’s no real metric to measure innovation. Researchers at Cornell University, INSEAD, and the World Intellectual Property Organization aspire to have the go-to benchmark, the way, say, S&P/Case-Shiller is for home prices.

For the 2014 edition of the index, the researchers ranked 143 nations based on 81 indicators ranging from the obvious, such as patent applications and high-tech exports, to the more questionable, such as YouTube uploads and press freedom.

I chose to drill down into 5 of the 81 indicators in the

    No results related

    Add now

study and chart the top 10 countries in each category, along with the U.S. The exercise immediately raised red flags about the index’s validity.

Estonia: No. 1U.S.: No. 37 As a share of the population, no other people are as devoted to creating or editing Wikipedia entries as Estonians are. That’s odd. What’s weirder, though, is that someone thought “Wikipedia edits” could be a proxy for innovation (though it could be argued that Wikipedia is a good platform for invention).

U.S.: No. 1 This chart is straightforward: These are the countries that produce the highest number of MBA aspirants. The metric, however, is not an entirely accurate proxy for how many people end up applying to business school. And, since the test is only offered in English, including it in the index privileges nations such as the U.S. Also, consider this: Consulting and finance are the top two industries employing MBA grads. Do you think of them as cradles of innovation?

Thailand: No. 1U.S.: No. 84 Upon viewing this chart, you might think, “Golly, look how far the U.S. trails behind!” Don’t be fooled—the countries are ranked by the percentof “tertiary” (read “college”) education graduates with a science or engineering degree, and not the absolute number. The U.S. has more college graduates than countries like Oman, Myanmar, Tunisia, and, yes, Thailand, and it would be hard to imagine more than 50 percent choosing science or engineering as their fields of study. And what of Iran? Are its science and engineering graduates staying in the country? Or are they emigrating abroad, where they might encounter greater opportunity.

Hong Kong: No. 1U.S.: unranked How reliable is this data set if the researchers couldn’t even include a number for the U.S.? It merits noting that several countries in the above chart are tax havens. Many of the businesses that register in those locales have no physical presence there, outside of a post office box.

Lesotho: No. 1U.S.: No. 45 This chart can be very misleading, and completely unjustified as a measure of innovation. Lesotho spends 13 percent of its gross domestic product on education, while the U.S. spends 5.4 percent. The GDP of the tiny African nation in 2010, the year the data correspond to, was $2.2 billion. For comparison, the New York City school district had an expenditure of $19 billion in 2010 (PDF), 8.6 times Lesotho’s GDP. And while Lesotho can be rightly proud of the fact that its adult literacy rate is among the highest in Africa, at 82 percent, it is still classified among the “low human development countries” by the United Nations.

There are 76 other factors considered, but on the basis of a closer examination of these five alone, it’s hard to take the index seriously. But don’t take our word for it. Explore the rest of the indicators for yourself here.

View Original Article: businessweek.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source businessweek.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"b","i":"1263394","t":"SPECIAL REPORT: \u2018It\u2019s easier to go into prison because York is the worst place to find anywhere to live\u2019","a":1},{"b":"a","i":"1324840","t":"Cops: Soldier Shot Near Canadian Parliament, Incident Ongoing","a":2},{"b":"a","i":"1324844","t":"Cops: Soldier Shot Near Canadian Parliament, Incident Ongoing","a":3},{"b":"a","i":"1324850","t":"Palomar Health board election attracts 14 candidates","a":4},{"b":"a","i":"1324838","t":"Market Wobbles Plunge Barclays PLC Into Bargain Territory! - Yahoo Finance UK","a":5},{"b":"a","i":"1324810","t":"Fallen trees causing delays as tail end of Hurricane Gonzalo hits south","a":6},{"b":"a","i":"1324811","t":"Hampshire police catch 16,000 drivers using mobile ahead of major safety sting","a":7},{"b":"b","i":"1263347","t":"Google highlights investments in Bluffs","a":8},{"b":"e","i":"527630","t":"The Simpsons World App Is Here. I Feel Like a Kid in Some Kind of Store.","a":9},{"b":"e","i":"527636","t":"What Was It Like to Work at NASA During the Challenger and Columbia Disasters?","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1324799","t":"Five things for Wednesday, Oct. 22","a":11},{"b":"a","i":"1324800","t":"Be Part of the Movement: Feed Hungry Kids, Fight Childhood Obesity and Keep Your Little Ones Healthy with Pocket Protein KIDZ - Yahoo India Finance","a":12},{"b":"c","i":"1878868","t":"Apple iPad Air 2","a":13},{"b":"a","i":"1324775","t":"Jennie, partners expanding care effort","a":14},{"b":"a","i":"1324776","t":"IPIB offering training in Atlantic","a":15},{"b":"a","i":"1324777","t":"West Pott. Extension offers training course","a":16},{"b":"a","i":"1324779","t":"Earling man killed in Shelby County ATV wreck","a":17},{"b":"e","i":"527629","t":"ScienceInsider","a":18},{"b":"d","i":"952855","t":"Probe into Ontario's unlicensed daycares to be released","a":19},{"b":"d","i":"952867","t":"Sask. economy to remain top priority in throne speech: premier","a":20},{"b":"d","i":"952882","t":"Diwali Desserts - Diwali Kheer (Rice Pudding)","a":21},{"b":"a","i":"1324757","t":"Storm off East Coast will keep clouds, rain in region for days","a":22},{"b":"e","i":"527619","t":"American Apartments Came From Paris","a":23},{"b":"c","i":"1878849","t":"Tim Cook meets with Chinese vice premier to 'exchange views' on data security","a":24},{"b":"a","i":"1324768","t":"There were loads more Brazilians in Ireland last year\u2026 And here\u2019s why* - Yahoo Finance UK","a":25},{"b":"a","i":"1324739","t":"Crystal Boyett in court today","a":26},{"b":"c","i":"1878843","t":"UCF team honored for making boy's arm with 3D printer","a":27},{"b":"a","i":"1324695","t":"Cameron defends record on NHS","a":28},{"b":"c","i":"1878827","t":"Revamp of NFL\u2019s domestic violence policy could take months, says ex-sex crimes prosecutor hired by league","a":29},{"b":"b","i":"1263280","t":"Wednesday, Oct. 22: Things to do today\/tonight","a":30},{"b":"b","i":"1263286","t":"Oscars: Neil Patrick Harris' huge challenge","a":31},{"b":"a","i":"1324679","t":"Carrington Charitable Foundation's 4th Annual Golf Classic Raises Over $1.4 Million for Wounded Heroes\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tThe Carrington Companies' Non-Profit Organization Hosts Event Benefiting Catastrophically Injured Veterans through the Carrington House","a":32},{"b":"a","i":"1324683","t":"Palladin Consumer Retail Partners Acquires Majority Interest in \n Harrys of London, Luxury Men\u2019s Footwear and Accessory Company","a":33},{"b":"a","i":"1324686","t":"Infinite Peripherals\u00ae Introduces First Enterprise Mobility Device for iPhone\u00ae 6 - Yahoo Finance UK","a":34},{"b":"e","i":"527579","t":"5 Social Security Changes Coming in 2015","a":35},{"b":"a","i":"1324692","t":"Consumer Prices in U.S. Rise 0.1% as Inflation Remains Muted","a":36},{"b":"a","i":"1324693","t":"iPhotonix Launches New OM3N Line of Active Ethernet Residential Gateway Solutions - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":37},{"b":"a","i":"1324694","t":"True Drinks Delivers on Phase One of Brand Awareness Campaign","a":38},{"b":"d","i":"952788","t":"Slave labor in America today","a":39},{"b":"b","i":"1263263","t":"Suspected serial killer due in Indiana court today","a":40},{"b":"a","i":"1324668","t":"Get Halloween ready with DoSavannah!","a":41},{"b":"b","i":"1263265","t":"Kasabian's Serge slams bland bands","a":42},{"b":"a","i":"1324642","t":"Neo Technology Kicks off GraphConnect 2014 With Record Number of Attendees","a":43},{"b":"a","i":"1324645","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":44},{"b":"b","i":"1263248","t":"Revolution Lighting Technologies Announces Reporting Date for Third \n Quarter of 2014","a":45},{"b":"b","i":"1263227","t":"Lost in Wilberforce","a":46},{"b":"b","i":"1263231","t":"VirnetX Granted New Secure Domain Name Patent - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":47},{"b":"b","i":"1263232","t":"Scorpio Bulkers Inc. Announces Commitment for a $42.0 Million Loan Facility","a":48},{"b":"b","i":"1263239","t":"Accomplished Media Executives Rick Hack and Linda Benjamin Join Truli Media Group","a":49},{"b":"b","i":"1263241","t":"AkzoNobel to divest 50 percent stake in Eka Synthomer Oy joint venture - Yahoo Finance UK","a":50},{"b":"b","i":"1263242","t":"Westinghouse Picks \u041c3 Communications for Its PR Agency in Bulgaria","a":51},{"b":"a","i":"1324629","t":"D.C. Council agenda","a":52},{"b":"d","i":"952734","t":"Global Velocity Joins the Internet2 Community","a":53},{"b":"d","i":"952737","t":"5-at-10: World Series, College Football Four, Gurley back? Rushmore of College football upsets","a":54},{"b":"d","i":"952743","t":"Cameron defends record on NHS","a":55},{"b":"d","i":"952749","t":"PSEG Long Island Names Paul Napoli Vice President Of Power Markets","a":56},{"b":"d","i":"952750","t":"Burger 21 Seeks Additional Franchisees for Greater Washington D.C. Expansion","a":57},{"b":"d","i":"952725","t":"Trinity College launches new strategic plan","a":58},{"b":"d","i":"952726","t":"World's Leading Young Social Entrepreneurs Meet at the 2014 Enactus World Cup","a":59},{"b":"b","i":"1263197","t":"Celltrion Healthcare: Experts share their \u201creal world\u201d experience of \n treating people with Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) with biosimilar \n anti-TNF\u03b1 monoclonal antibody (mAb)","a":60},{"b":"b","i":"1263200","t":"Bad weather forces cruise liner into Liverpool","a":61},{"b":"b","i":"1263204","t":"Zacks Industry Outlook Highlights: Deutsche Bank, HSBC Holdings, Barclays, Bank of Montreal and Royal Bank of Scotland","a":62},{"b":"b","i":"1263188","t":"Universal Pictures' Ouija Brings Halloween Spirit to Popular Mobile App PicCollage - Yahoo Finance UK","a":63},{"b":"b","i":"1263189","t":"Sprint Delivers Industry-Leading Network Reliability and Call Performance in Albany, New York - Yahoo India Finance","a":64},{"b":"b","i":"1263190","t":"Bayer Launches Versatile Solution for Roadside Managers with Derigo Herbicide\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tDerigo provides a full utility spectrum to offer a one-stop solution for post-emergent weed control and plant growth regulation","a":65},{"b":"b","i":"1263191","t":"India 2nd fastest growing air cargo market after Middle East","a":66},{"b":"b","i":"1263192","t":"VIDEO: Maddox family's \"one cow\" philosophy changed industry","a":67},{"b":"b","i":"1263193","t":"Howard Johnson Launches Nationwide Search for Stars of 1960s' Campaign","a":68},{"b":"a","i":"1324552","t":"McDonald's Discovers Its Inner Locavore and Learns to Love Regionalism","a":69},{"b":"a","i":"1324553","t":"Validian to Present Its Revolutionary Cyber Security Technology at Upcoming FireRock Conference in NYC - Yahoo India Finance","a":70},{"b":"a","i":"1324554","t":"Epazz Reports 21 Percent Increase in Revenues for First Half of 2014; Epazz Will Be Uplisting to the OTCQB Before the End of the Month","a":71},{"b":"a","i":"1324555","t":"Ascent Secures New Tenant in CH2 Data Center Colocation Suite - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":72},{"b":"e","i":"527550","t":"Consumer Prices in U.S. Rise 0.1% as Inflation Remains Muted","a":73},{"b":"d","i":"952678","t":"Education chiefs set Bradford schools 'ambitious' challenge to hike standards by 2017","a":74},{"b":"e","i":"527536","t":"GTAT And Apple May Reach A Deal. Doesn't Mean The Stock Is Worth Anything","a":75},{"b":"d","i":"952654","t":"Quest Diagnostics Adds Jeffrey M. Leiden, M.D., Ph.D., to Board of Directors","a":76},{"b":"d","i":"952647","t":"Athlete Spotlight for Wednesday, October 22, 2014.","a":77},{"b":"b","i":"1263162","t":"Whea tKings go west","a":78},{"b":"b","i":"1263132","t":"Top cowboys lock horns for bull ride","a":79},{"b":"e","i":"527505","t":"Startup Aims To Remake Computer Security For the Cloud Age","a":80},{"b":"f","i":"1152631","t":"10 Things to Know for Today","a":81},{"b":"b","i":"1263104","t":"Home \/ Analysis \/ Mailroom & Packaging Category Analysis: First past the post","a":82},{"b":"b","i":"1263077","t":"Idaho North Resources Enters into Earn-In Option Agreement with Coeur Mining - Yahoo India Finance","a":83},{"b":"b","i":"1263085","t":"Specialist police are searching in the water after wheelchair found on bank of River Test near Romsey","a":84},{"b":"b","i":"1263087","t":"PlayPhone Partners with Mobily to Bring Next Generation Mobile Gaming \n to Middle East","a":85},{"b":"d","i":"952587","t":"RentPath Announces Equity Investment from Providence Equity Partners, Now Equal Owners with TPG","a":86},{"b":"d","i":"952590","t":"Enigma Diagnostics Signs Joint Venture Agreement with Beijing Leadman Biochemistry and Announces US$50 Million ...","a":87},{"b":"d","i":"952591","t":"Jumei Cooperates with Two New Global Brands and Strengthens Anti-Counterfeit Measures","a":88},{"b":"d","i":"952597","t":"Zecotek Announces Two New Patent Publications Covering Advanced LFS Crystal Formulations and Silicon Photo-Detectors","a":89},{"b":"d","i":"952601","t":"Kenny G Hits a Sour Note With China's Government","a":90},{"b":"b","i":"1263046","t":"North Korea cites Obama requests in freeing US prisoner","a":91},{"b":"b","i":"1263066","t":"Enigma Diagnostics Signs Joint Venture Agreement with Beijing Leadman Biochemistry and Announces US$50 Million Investment - Yahoo7 Finance Australia","a":92},{"b":"d","i":"952549","t":"Total S.A. UK Regulatory Announcement: Total's Board of Directors Pays Homage to Christophe De Margerie and Organizes ...","a":93},{"b":"c","i":"1878680","t":"Featured Stories","a":94},{"b":"d","i":"952504","t":"Financial Institutions Set to Transition Entirely into Paperless, Secure and Compliant Data Processing, as Docupace ...","a":95},{"b":"d","i":"952507","t":"Fireman's Brew Announces New Stock Offering for Accredited Investors, Joins Innovative Equity Crowdfunding Platform ...","a":96},{"b":"c","i":"1878662","t":"Ohio Politics Now: More talk of Kasich running for president","a":97},{"b":"d","i":"952494","t":"Markets Live: Shares rally another day","a":98},{"b":"d","i":"952479","t":"Meralco outlasts Barako Bull in double OT","a":99},{"b":"d","i":"952457","t":"A New Title from NTT Solmare's "Shall we date?" Series, "Shall we date?: THE NIFLHEIM+" Is Now Released!","a":100}]

      100

      SPECIAL REPORT: ‘It’s easier to go into prison because York is the worst place to find anywhere to live’