English | Italian

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
no related videos
Pop theme

Scottish independence,Alex Salmond,Taliban,Afghan election,Larry Ellison,Alan Pardew,Jameis Winston,Eric Matthew,Django Unchained,Ole Gunnar

Related theme

hard take

A Highly Dubious Measure of Innovation

A Highly Dubious Measure of Innovation

2014-07-30 09:56:44

When you think “innovation,” do Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and Sweden come to mind? No? Well, those countries are at the top of the annual Global Innovation Index, released last Friday.

In case you hadn’t noticed, “innovation” has become quite the buzzword. It attracts attention, particularly in business circles. However, there’s no real metric to measure innovation. Researchers at Cornell University, INSEAD, and the World Intellectual Property Organization aspire to have the go-to benchmark, the way, say, S&P/Case-Shiller is for home prices.

For the 2014 edition of the index, the researchers ranked 143 nations based on 81 indicators ranging from the obvious, such as patent applications and high-tech exports, to the more questionable, such as YouTube uploads and press freedom.

I chose to drill down into 5 of the 81 indicators in the

study and chart the top 10 countries in each category, along with the U.S. The exercise immediately raised red flags about the index’s validity.

Estonia: No. 1U.S.: No. 37 As a share of the population, no other people are as devoted to creating or editing Wikipedia entries as Estonians are. That’s odd. What’s weirder, though, is that someone thought “Wikipedia edits” could be a proxy for innovation (though it could be argued that Wikipedia is a good platform for invention).

U.S.: No. 1 This chart is straightforward: These are the countries that produce the highest number of MBA aspirants. The metric, however, is not an entirely accurate proxy for how many people end up applying to business school. And, since the test is only offered in English, including it in the index privileges nations such as the U.S. Also, consider this: Consulting and finance are the top two industries employing MBA grads. Do you think of them as cradles of innovation?

Thailand: No. 1U.S.: No. 84 Upon viewing this chart, you might think, “Golly, look how far the U.S. trails behind!” Don’t be fooled—the countries are ranked by the percentof “tertiary” (read “college”) education graduates with a science or engineering degree, and not the absolute number. The U.S. has more college graduates than countries like Oman, Myanmar, Tunisia, and, yes, Thailand, and it would be hard to imagine more than 50 percent choosing science or engineering as their fields of study. And what of Iran? Are its science and engineering graduates staying in the country? Or are they emigrating abroad, where they might encounter greater opportunity.

Hong Kong: No. 1U.S.: unranked How reliable is this data set if the researchers couldn’t even include a number for the U.S.? It merits noting that several countries in the above chart are tax havens. Many of the businesses that register in those locales have no physical presence there, outside of a post office box.

Lesotho: No. 1U.S.: No. 45 This chart can be very misleading, and completely unjustified as a measure of innovation. Lesotho spends 13 percent of its gross domestic product on education, while the U.S. spends 5.4 percent. The GDP of the tiny African nation in 2010, the year the data correspond to, was $2.2 billion. For comparison, the New York City school district had an expenditure of $19 billion in 2010 (PDF), 8.6 times Lesotho’s GDP. And while Lesotho can be rightly proud of the fact that its adult literacy rate is among the highest in Africa, at 82 percent, it is still classified among the “low human development countries” by the United Nations.

There are 76 other factors considered, but on the basis of a closer examination of these five alone, it’s hard to take the index seriously. But don’t take our word for it. Explore the rest of the indicators for yourself here.

View Original Article: businessweek.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source businessweek.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"c","i":"1818405","t":"Accused Cop Shooter Eric Frein Reenacting Rambo, Colleague Suggests","a":1},{"b":"d","i":"864573","t":"F1: Friday press conference - Singapore","a":2},{"b":"e","i":"504669","t":"Survey: Just how happy are you, New York?","a":3},{"b":"d","i":"864560","t":"HK & China Snapshot","a":4},{"b":"c","i":"1818372","t":"stltoday.com","a":5},{"b":"d","i":"864538","t":"iHealth Raises $25 Million to Fuel Growth and Global Market Share","a":6},{"b":"f","i":"1076525","t":"Message to the White House Email List: \"It's On Us\"","a":7},{"b":"e","i":"504656","t":"Hillary Clinton Summons Sisterhood, Decries NFL Assaults","a":8},{"b":"e","i":"504657","t":"Citibank Loses Bid to Appeal Argentina Bond Payment Case","a":9},{"b":"c","i":"1818361","t":"The Alibaba IPO and Other Fascinating News on the Web","a":10},{"b":"d","i":"864513","t":"Simon Dyson eyes Welsh wow","a":11},{"b":"d","i":"864506","t":"Veresen Announces Common Share Dividend for September 2014","a":12},{"b":"d","i":"864463","t":"Man pleads guilty to US embassy bombings which killed 224","a":13},{"b":"d","i":"864423","t":"Shropshire passengers hit as 200,000 trains are cancelled in a year","a":14},{"b":"d","i":"864391","t":"T N Ninan: Moving into South Asia","a":15},{"b":"d","i":"864401","t":"Perkins Eastman Celebrates Ribbon Cutting of Tulsa Jewish Retirement and Health Center in Tulsa, OK","a":16},{"b":"d","i":"864363","t":"BlackRock Equity Option Closed-End Funds Announce Change of Fiscal Year-End","a":17},{"b":"d","i":"864365","t":"SIM Saddened by Recent Attack on Ebola Aid Workers in Guinea","a":18},{"b":"d","i":"864340","t":"Weber votes for jobs and energy independence","a":19},{"b":"d","i":"864307","t":"Gold settles at lowest price this year, miners hit new 52-week lows","a":20},{"b":"d","i":"864310","t":"Restaurants renew farm-to-table dining concept in York County. Has its time come?","a":21},{"b":"d","i":"864314","t":"Gillmor Gang LIVE 09.19.14","a":22},{"b":"d","i":"864327","t":"Alnylam to Webcast Presentation at 21st Annual NewsMakers in the Biotech Industry Conference","a":23},{"b":"d","i":"864331","t":"Gold logs third straight weekly drop, miners hit new lows","a":24},{"b":"c","i":"1818256","t":"Thinking of buying some Alibaba stock? This chart will help","a":25},{"b":"d","i":"864296","t":"Incheon Asian Games 2014 open in 'Gangnam Style'","a":26},{"b":"d","i":"864298","t":"Nat'l five, Lee off to Korea today","a":27},{"b":"f","i":"1076363","t":"Alibaba debuts on Wall Street with largest-ever IPO","a":28},{"b":"d","i":"864278","t":"Law enforcement's domestic abuse problem","a":29},{"b":"f","i":"1076367","t":"Thinking of buying some Alibaba stock? This chart will help","a":30},{"b":"f","i":"1076371","t":"Alibaba Would Be The 12th Biggest Company In The S&P 500","a":31},{"b":"f","i":"1076352","t":"Alice suspect former home searched","a":32},{"b":"d","i":"864249","t":"Press Briefing by Press Secretary Josh Earnest, 9\/18\/2014","a":33},{"b":"f","i":"1076303","t":"The 5 best iOS apps for International Talk Like A Pirate Day","a":34},{"b":"d","i":"864208","t":"Faster, cheaper Internet on tap for Downtown ABQ, UNM","a":35},{"b":"e","i":"504584","t":"Samsung's Galaxy Note 4 Smartphone Now Available for Preorder","a":36},{"b":"d","i":"864153","t":"Supporting the America Cup 2014 (Para Soccer): Canada Soccer Receives Government of Canada Funding to Host Continental ...","a":37},{"b":"d","i":"864155","t":"Baird to address UN Security Council on Iraq after American invite","a":38},{"b":"d","i":"864120","t":"Action Report: Total sinks like a stone in UConn-USF matchup","a":39},{"b":"d","i":"864130","t":"The FTSE 100\u2032s Hottest Growth Stocks: ARM Holdings plc","a":40},{"b":"d","i":"864091","t":"Methanex Restarts Chile Plant","a":41},{"b":"d","i":"864100","t":"The African Development Bank Confronts A Changing Africa","a":42},{"b":"c","i":"1818170","t":"Gunman gets 21 years in fatal barbershop shooting","a":43},{"b":"e","i":"504568","t":"Would You Try This Floating-Eyeliner Look?","a":44},{"b":"f","i":"1076223","t":"Yahoo Valued at Less Than Asian Assets After Alibaba IPO","a":45},{"b":"d","i":"864078","t":"FIA Friday press conference - Singapore","a":46},{"b":"e","i":"504554","t":"When I Was 5, I, Um -- What Were We Just Talking About? | Mother Jones","a":47},{"b":"e","i":"504559","t":"Ray Rice Jersey Line Longer Than iPhone 6 Line -- NYMag","a":48},{"b":"f","i":"1076273","t":"Parents of Missing UVA Student Urge 'Walk With a Buddy'","a":49},{"b":"f","i":"1076215","t":"Alex Salmond to resign as Scotland's First Minister","a":50},{"b":"f","i":"1076187","t":"President Obama Launches the \"It's On Us\" Campaign to End Sexual Assault on Campus","a":51},{"b":"d","i":"864007","t":"Apple Fans Throng Retail Stores For New IPhones","a":52},{"b":"f","i":"1076287","t":"Stocks Creating Buzz Today","a":53},{"b":"c","i":"1818110","t":"Obama Says ‘It’s on Us’ to Prevent Sexual Assault","a":54},{"b":"c","i":"1818106","t":"Conan's fake Apple commercial has ultimate U2 solution","a":55},{"b":"e","i":"504483","t":"ScienceInsider","a":56},{"b":"f","i":"1076063","t":"Stocks rise slightly at midday as Alibaba debuts","a":57},{"b":"f","i":"1076047","t":"Today Scotland Is Stronger","a":58},{"b":"f","i":"1076171","t":"Never mind Alibaba IPO, quadruple witching hour is what's stirring markets today","a":59},{"b":"e","i":"504420","t":"Etro's Swaying, Bohemian Footwear","a":60},{"b":"f","i":"1075974","t":"See Which Brands Are Talking Like Pirates on Twitter Today","a":61},{"b":"c","i":"1818053","t":"Scotland referendum: Alex Salmond to quit as leader of Scottish National Party","a":62},{"b":"f","i":"1076144","t":"Police search Charlottesville apartment, car for clues into disappearance of Hannah Graham","a":63},{"b":"e","i":"504390","t":"Alibaba's Debut: Slow and Successful","a":64},{"b":"e","i":"504391","t":"Another China-Japan Fight, This Time Over Condoms","a":65},{"b":"c","i":"1818002","t":"Scotland referendum: Alex Salmond quits as leader of Scottish National Party","a":66},{"b":"f","i":"1076149","t":"Car Seized, Apartment Searched in Hunt For Missing UVA Student","a":67},{"b":"e","i":"504362","t":"Viral Video of the Day: Proud iPhone 6 Owner Drops It On Live TV - The Daily Beast","a":68},{"b":"c","i":"1817985","t":"Graphic: British territories, then and now","a":69},{"b":"e","i":"504346","t":"Old Navy's Newest Ad Involves Babies and Kittens","a":70},{"b":"f","i":"1076152","t":"Police Search Apartment in Connection With Missing UVA Student","a":71},{"b":"c","i":"1817959","t":"Transit Police report fewer smartphone thefts on the T this year","a":72},{"b":"c","i":"1817865","t":"Keyboard Apps Dominate The App Store’s Top Charts After iOS 8 Release","a":73},{"b":"f","i":"1075544","t":"Remembering Brian Clough: An outsider who'd mourn today's foreign greed and ignorance to soccer history","a":74},{"b":"f","i":"1075574","t":"Alibaba's Jack Ma Absolutely Loves 'Forrest Gump'","a":75},{"b":"f","i":"1075577","t":"Marissa Mayer Could Buy AOL Tomorrow If She Wanted To \u2014 A Deal Tim Armstrong Has Wanted In The Past","a":76},{"b":"f","i":"1075694","t":"BCT Atoms seeks seventh, UB eyes fifth","a":77},{"b":"c","i":"1817816","t":"AM Sacramento: Here’s what you need to know for Friday","a":78},{"b":"e","i":"504304","t":"Alibaba Just Went Public -- NYMag","a":79},{"b":"e","i":"504263","t":"Alibaba Chair Inspired By 'Hero' Forrest Gump, Calls New Wealth 'Headache'","a":80},{"b":"g","i":"23706","t":"\u2122[[Nevada\u2122]] Ms. Olympia,2014,Live,Stream,Finals,Fitness,Bikini,Today,at,2014","a":81},{"b":"c","i":"1817762","t":"Alibaba's IPO debut delayed on first day of trading","a":82},{"b":"e","i":"504233","t":"Twiggy Turns 65 | InStyle","a":83},{"b":"e","i":"504234","t":"‘ER’ Debuted 20 Years Ago Today | InStyle","a":84},{"b":"f","i":"1075268","t":"It's On Every Single One of Us","a":85},{"b":"a","i":"1239806","t":"5 things to know for Thursday Sept. 18, 2014","a":86},{"b":"f","i":"1075246","t":"The Days of BABA Are Upon Us","a":87},{"b":"a","i":"1239878","t":"Frontier Communications Appoints Ken Arndt President of New East Region - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":88},{"b":"a","i":"1239884","t":"Nigeria Security Forces Routinely Use Torture: Amnesty","a":89},{"b":"a","i":"1239905","t":"Fed keeps rates low, but brace for the inevitable","a":90},{"b":"a","i":"1239910","t":"Air Canada Aligns Domestic First Checked Bag Policy with Other Canadian Carriers - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":91},{"b":"a","i":"1239930","t":"France strikes IS depot in Iraq","a":92},{"b":"a","i":"1239745","t":"Greek unemployment drops to 26.6% in second quarter","a":93},{"b":"f","i":"1075197","t":"Rappler Newscast | September 19, 2014","a":94},{"b":"a","i":"1239762","t":"Bank borrowing in new ECB programme below forecasts","a":95},{"b":"a","i":"1239796","t":"Kent County Health Department nabs national honor - and it's apples for all","a":96},{"b":"a","i":"1239819","t":"Adrian Peterson and Greg Hardy Put on NFL's Exempt List","a":97},{"b":"a","i":"1239875","t":"Houston Joins Dallas Creating U.S. Millionaires Fastest","a":98},{"b":"f","i":"1075201","t":"What you need to know: Friday","a":99},{"b":"a","i":"1239904","t":"Second crash on Denbighshire 'danger' road in a week","a":100}]

      100

      Accused Cop Shooter Eric Frein Reenacting Rambo, Colleague Suggests