English | Italian

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
no related videos
Pop theme

Bibeau,Europe budget,Joko Widodo,Ebola Virus,Bharatiya Janata Party,Oscar Pistorius,Dilma Rousseff,Jeffrey Fowle,Taylor Swift,Zellweger

Related theme

lesotho percent

A Highly Dubious Measure of Innovation

2014-07-30 09:56:44

When you think “innovation,” do Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and Sweden come to mind? No? Well, those countries are at the top of the annual Global Innovation Index, released last Friday.

In case you hadn’t noticed, “innovation” has become quite the buzzword. It attracts attention, particularly in business circles. However, there’s no real metric to measure innovation. Researchers at Cornell University, INSEAD, and the World Intellectual Property Organization aspire to have the go-to benchmark, the way, say, S&P/Case-Shiller is for home prices.

For the 2014 edition of the index, the researchers ranked 143 nations based on 81 indicators ranging from the obvious, such as patent applications and high-tech exports, to the more questionable, such as YouTube uploads and press freedom.

I chose to drill down into 5 of the 81 indicators in the

    No results related

    Add now

study and chart the top 10 countries in each category, along with the U.S. The exercise immediately raised red flags about the index’s validity.

Estonia: No. 1U.S.: No. 37 As a share of the population, no other people are as devoted to creating or editing Wikipedia entries as Estonians are. That’s odd. What’s weirder, though, is that someone thought “Wikipedia edits” could be a proxy for innovation (though it could be argued that Wikipedia is a good platform for invention).

U.S.: No. 1 This chart is straightforward: These are the countries that produce the highest number of MBA aspirants. The metric, however, is not an entirely accurate proxy for how many people end up applying to business school. And, since the test is only offered in English, including it in the index privileges nations such as the U.S. Also, consider this: Consulting and finance are the top two industries employing MBA grads. Do you think of them as cradles of innovation?

Thailand: No. 1U.S.: No. 84 Upon viewing this chart, you might think, “Golly, look how far the U.S. trails behind!” Don’t be fooled—the countries are ranked by the percentof “tertiary” (read “college”) education graduates with a science or engineering degree, and not the absolute number. The U.S. has more college graduates than countries like Oman, Myanmar, Tunisia, and, yes, Thailand, and it would be hard to imagine more than 50 percent choosing science or engineering as their fields of study. And what of Iran? Are its science and engineering graduates staying in the country? Or are they emigrating abroad, where they might encounter greater opportunity.

Hong Kong: No. 1U.S.: unranked How reliable is this data set if the researchers couldn’t even include a number for the U.S.? It merits noting that several countries in the above chart are tax havens. Many of the businesses that register in those locales have no physical presence there, outside of a post office box.

Lesotho: No. 1U.S.: No. 45 This chart can be very misleading, and completely unjustified as a measure of innovation. Lesotho spends 13 percent of its gross domestic product on education, while the U.S. spends 5.4 percent. The GDP of the tiny African nation in 2010, the year the data correspond to, was $2.2 billion. For comparison, the New York City school district had an expenditure of $19 billion in 2010 (PDF), 8.6 times Lesotho’s GDP. And while Lesotho can be rightly proud of the fact that its adult literacy rate is among the highest in Africa, at 82 percent, it is still classified among the “low human development countries” by the United Nations.

There are 76 other factors considered, but on the basis of a closer examination of these five alone, it’s hard to take the index seriously. But don’t take our word for it. Explore the rest of the indicators for yourself here.

View Original Article: businessweek.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source businessweek.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"A Highly Dubious Measure of..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"b","i":"1272044","t":"One Percent’s politics of nothing: Why inequality is absent in these midterms","a":1},{"b":"b","i":"1272004","t":"Manitex International, Inc. will Report 2014 Third Quarter Financial Results on November 6, 2014 - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":2},{"b":"b","i":"1272005","t":"RadNet, Inc. Announces Date of Its Third Quarter 2014 Financial Results Conference Call - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":3},{"b":"b","i":"1272011","t":"StoneMor Partners L.P. Announces Increased Distribution and Date for Conference Call to Discuss 2014 Third Quarter Financial Results - Yahoo7 Finance Australia","a":4},{"b":"a","i":"1333948","t":"Sharapova concedes No.1 ranking to Serena","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1272018","t":"Dream Payments Honoured With Innovation Award for Mobile Point of Sale Solution","a":6},{"b":"b","i":"1272025","t":"Advice for farmers","a":7},{"b":"b","i":"1272027","t":"National Study: Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center Named Among America's 100 Best Hospitals for Cardiac Care - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":8},{"b":"b","i":"1272028","t":"San Francisco jail offering computer tablets to inmates","a":9},{"b":"c","i":"1883058","t":"Jury begins deliberating in 1979 ‘cold case’ slaying","a":10},{"b":"b","i":"1271989","t":"Kansas' NPLEx Technology Making Significant Progress\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tPoint-Of-Sale System Blocks Illegal Pseudoephedrine Sales But Protects Lawful Purchase","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1271991","t":"Man shot, killed when Cumberland County deputies try to serve warrants","a":12},{"b":"b","i":"1271997","t":"Iran must halt imminent execution of 26-year-old woman, Reyhaneh Jabbari","a":13},{"b":"e","i":"529685","t":"FULHAM vs. CHARLTON ATHLETIC Live Stream Online: 2014 English League Championship Table, Live Coverage From London, Projected Lineups and TACTICAL PREVIEW","a":14},{"b":"e","i":"529692","t":"Queen Elizabeth Makes Twitter Debut","a":15},{"b":"a","i":"1333928","t":"Finally Buy that KitchenAid, New Pairs of Jeans, and More Deals","a":16},{"b":"b","i":"1272002","t":"How to Earn the Right to Buy Ferrari’s Most Exclusive Hypercar","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1271973","t":"Essential security apps for your phone or tablet","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1271969","t":"Ford Posts Third Quarter 2014 Pre-Tax Profit of $1.2\n Billion*; Net Income of $835 Million; Global Product Launches on Track,\n Including F-150","a":19},{"b":"e","i":"529658","t":"What To Do When You're Not The Pretty One","a":20},{"b":"c","i":"1883029","t":"Apartment of NYC doctor with Ebola is decontaminated","a":21},{"b":"c","i":"1883035","t":"Aluminum Caps Biggest Two-Day Slide in Three Weeks","a":22},{"b":"b","i":"1271965","t":"Featured Brokers","a":23},{"b":"e","i":"529647","t":"Dallas Nurse Nina Pham Tests Negative for Ebola -- NYMag","a":24},{"b":"e","i":"529652","t":"Domenico Dolce & Stefano Gabbana Exonerated","a":25},{"b":"c","i":"1883024","t":"3 Awkward Celebrity Interactions With Secretary of State John Kerry","a":26},{"b":"a","i":"1333870","t":"Amazon’s Fire TV blazes ahead, adds Spotify, NFL Now, and more","a":27},{"b":"b","i":"1271900","t":"Featured Brokers","a":28},{"b":"a","i":"1333852","t":"Masa eyeing 15 gold in WSK challenge","a":29},{"b":"a","i":"1333860","t":"Rescuer of toddler who climbed out window onto busy road gets bravery award - Yahoo News UK","a":30},{"b":"a","i":"1333862","t":"Understanding the secrets of Canada's northern ecology: Dr. Charles Krebs Awarded Lifetime Achievement Prize in Northern Research by The W. Garfield Weston Foundation - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":31},{"b":"d","i":"958527","t":"Glico's running man now lit up with LEDs","a":32},{"b":"b","i":"1271924","t":"Shire CEO Ornskov \u2018Dumbfounded\u2019 by AbbVie Deal Collapse","a":33},{"b":"f","i":"1156779","t":"Ottawa shooting: Cpl. Nathan Cirillo's body going home to Hamilton","a":34},{"b":"a","i":"1333809","t":"Globant to Announce Third Quarter Financial Results on November 10","a":35},{"b":"a","i":"1333818","t":"Viteos Awarded Best Shadow-accounting Firm\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tMarket Leader Recognized for Category Creation, Innovation, Client Service","a":36},{"b":"a","i":"1333826","t":"Parallels is Telecom Italia Digital Solutions Technical Partner to \n Speed up the Cloud Automation Adoption of Telcos and IT Distributors by \n Supporting their GTM Process","a":37},{"b":"b","i":"1271873","t":"BasicBites\u2122 Becomes Official Oral Care Product of the New York Islanders\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tBreakthrough Soft Chews Help Maintain Healthy Teeth and Support a Balanced Oral pH","a":38},{"b":"b","i":"1271876","t":"Other stories from today:","a":39},{"b":"b","i":"1271848","t":"Pakistan parliament's anti-India resolution an 'act of desperation': BJP","a":40},{"b":"a","i":"1333792","t":"#AskTIME Subcriber Q and A: Haley Sweetland Edwards","a":41},{"b":"a","i":"1333795","t":"Featured Brokers","a":42},{"b":"e","i":"529595","t":"Obama to Meet with Nurse Who Had Ebola","a":43},{"b":"f","i":"1156732","t":"Ebola in NYC Is 'No Cause for Alarm,' Mayor Says","a":44},{"b":"e","i":"529592","t":"8@8: your morning scoop","a":45},{"b":"a","i":"1333764","t":"Harper Government Focused on Canadian Jobs - Yahoo Finance UK","a":46},{"b":"a","i":"1333768","t":"Globant to Announce Third Quarter Financial Results on November 10 - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":47},{"b":"f","i":"1156703","t":"The Queen Sends Her First Tweet","a":48},{"b":"e","i":"529565","t":"NIH Says Dallas Nurse Now Ebola-Free, Will Be Released From Hospital","a":49},{"b":"a","i":"1333756","t":"New climate intergovernmentalism: Will the EU deliver?","a":50},{"b":"b","i":"1271813","t":"EMV Migration Forum Releases Statement on Federal Government's BuySecure Initiative - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":51},{"b":"a","i":"1333723","t":"Corbett Administration Approves Funding to Support Community Planning and Shared Services","a":52},{"b":"e","i":"529548","t":"The Cast of “Laggies” Is Glad That High School Is Over | InStyle","a":53},{"b":"b","i":"1271760","t":"K\u00f6v\u00e9r: Hungary could leave the EU","a":54},{"b":"b","i":"1271770","t":"Dallas Nurse Treated For Ebola Released From Hospital Virus-Free","a":55},{"b":"a","i":"1333679","t":"Guernsey County and its surrounding areas meeting and events calendar","a":56},{"b":"b","i":"1271752","t":"Tri-States schedule Halloween fun for all","a":57},{"b":"f","i":"1156698","t":"Slain soldier returning home today: police","a":58},{"b":"a","i":"1333643","t":"Community Foundation to build, move to Cedar Falls next year","a":59},{"b":"a","i":"1333644","t":"Kubota Expands Popular \u201cKommander\u201d Residential Zero-Turn Mower Line with All-New Z122R - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":60},{"b":"a","i":"1333649","t":"BasicBites\u2122 Becomes Official Oral Care Product of the New York Islanders - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":61},{"b":"f","i":"1156653","t":"Ebola 'Poses No Threat to Others,' NYC Mayor Says","a":62},{"b":"b","i":"1271710","t":"Marseille's culture clash: An old hatred acquires a new face","a":63},{"b":"a","i":"1333627","t":"Glendalough Irish Whiskey Launch New Offering at Ireland\u2019s Premier \n Whiskey Event","a":64},{"b":"b","i":"1271682","t":"Personnel Today Awards 2014 shortlist: Employer Branding","a":65},{"b":"c","i":"1882890","t":"Featured Stories","a":66},{"b":"b","i":"1271689","t":"Tara Lipinski, Johnny Weir to Host NBC Figure Skating","a":67},{"b":"a","i":"1333608","t":"Senior JD(U) leader Jagannath Mishra sees Nehru in Narendra Modi","a":68},{"b":"a","i":"1333609","t":"Exclusive excerpt: How sexism helped turn tide for Hazel McCallion | Toronto Star","a":69},{"b":"a","i":"1333613","t":"Magnotta murder trial hears police experts analyzed accused's laptops - Yahoo News Canada","a":70},{"b":"b","i":"1271673","t":"Opera singer Eric Jordan sings his way through stroke recovery process","a":71},{"b":"a","i":"1333587","t":"Robinson misses practice, Sunday status is in doubt | Access Vikings | StarTribune.com","a":72},{"b":"d","i":"958465","t":"Emirati\u2019s love affair with stamps spans 44 years","a":73},{"b":"c","i":"1882873","t":"Procter & Gamble Co. Earnings: Cashing Out of the Battery Business","a":74},{"b":"a","i":"1333573","t":"Ex-Im Bank Links With Development Authority Of The North Country To Boost Regional Exports\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tNew Partnership Comes After Ex-Im Bank Roundtable Convened in April by Gillibrand and Owens","a":75},{"b":"a","i":"1333583","t":"How Retirement Was Invented","a":76},{"b":"a","i":"1333547","t":"The Denver Broncos are on pace to be one of history's great teams | Shutdown Corner - Yahoo Sports Canada","a":77},{"b":"a","i":"1333550","t":"'Fortunate and blessed': Nina Pham beats Ebola | Health - KETV Home","a":78},{"b":"c","i":"1882859","t":"Texas Nurse 'Blessed' To Be Cured Of Ebola","a":79},{"b":"a","i":"1333530","t":"Texas Nurse 'Blessed' To Be Cured Of Ebola - Yahoo News UK","a":80},{"b":"e","i":"529466","t":"Pain Begins to Spread as China's Home Prices Fall for Fifth Straight Month","a":81},{"b":"e","i":"529469","t":"New York Man Diagnosed With Ebola, Health Officials Tracing His Contacts","a":82},{"b":"e","i":"529476","t":"Political Aide in Bondage Bar: Tabloid Scandals Weaken Abe","a":83},{"b":"a","i":"1333529","t":"Randgold Resources Limited: Preparedness Spurs Prompt Response to Mali's First Ebola Case - Yahoo Finance UK","a":84},{"b":"e","i":"529446","t":"Why Target, J.C.Penney, and Gap's New CEOs Have To Learn To Be Merchants","a":85},{"b":"c","i":"1882833","t":"Windows 10 is the Most Audacious Release in the History of the Platform","a":86},{"b":"b","i":"1271577","t":"BDC Now: Cigarette Company Bans Smoking in the Workplace","a":87},{"b":"d","i":"958441","t":"Putin: US Unable to Handle Unipolar World","a":88},{"b":"f","i":"1156604","t":"Volunteers deliver emergency kits to seniors","a":89},{"b":"b","i":"1271545","t":"Harper Government supports women-led businesses in British Columbia - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":90},{"b":"f","i":"1156607","t":"Heartbreaking scene at home of slain Canadian soldier","a":91},{"b":"f","i":"1156608","t":"Postmedia Network Reports Fourth Quarter Results","a":92},{"b":"f","i":"1156614","t":"Canadian Muslim groups denounce violence, brace for backlash following Ottawa shooting | video","a":93},{"b":"f","i":"1156571","t":"Ebola Hysterics: Twitter Offers Ebola Panic Levity","a":94},{"b":"c","i":"1882767","t":"Our headline from 1965: 'Mystery' Industry Is Disney","a":95},{"b":"c","i":"1882742","t":"State: Ballot question won't impact controversial Fenimore landfill cleanup","a":96},{"b":"f","i":"1156490","t":"[XTREAM]!!!@Watch .The Book of Life. [FULL-MOVIE] online-free!!! -","a":97},{"b":"f","i":"1156516","t":"Heartbreaking scene at home of slain Canadian soldier","a":98},{"b":"c","i":"1882737","t":"Luxury Smartphones for Status Seekers Starting at $6,900","a":99},{"b":"f","i":"1156522","t":"Postmedia Network Reports Fourth Quarter Results","a":100}]

      100

      One Percent’s politics of nothing: Why inequality is absent in these midterms