English | Italian

"Diet Drugs Work: Why..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
G7 Chiều thứ 3: VOA: OBESITY RISES AMONG CHILDREN IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
PNGDF moves to fight obesity in the force
What Are the Dangers of Obesity in Children
What Are the Dangers of Obesity in Children
What Are the Dangers of Obesity in Children
Childhood obesity - blitz obesity in kids with Freaky Rivet's activities
Continue »
Pop theme

Bibeau,Europe budget,Joko Widodo,Ebola Virus,Bharatiya Janata Party,Oscar Pistorius,Dilma Rousseff,Jeffrey Fowle,Taylor Swift,Zellweger

Related theme

primary care,boston “

Diet Drugs Work: Why Won’t Doctors Prescribe Them?


obesity em “

2013-12-05 10:59:14

The woman sat on my exam table and pointed to her snug paper gown. “Doctor,” she said, “I need your help losing weight.”

I spent the next several minutes speaking with her about diet and exercise, the health risks of obesity, and the benefits of weight loss—a talk I’ve been having with my patients for more than twenty years. But, like the majority of Americans, most of my patients remain overweight.

Afterward, I realized that what my patient wanted was a pill that would make her lose weight. I could have prescribed her one of four drugs currently approved by the F.D.A.: two, phentermine and orlistat, that have been around for more than a decade, and two others, Belviq (lorcaserin) and Qsymia (a combination of phentermine and topiramate), that have recently come onto the market

and are the first ever approved for long-term use. (Ian Parker wrote about the F.D.A.‘s approval process for new medications in this week's issue.) The drugs work by suppressing appetite, by increasing metabolism, and by other mechanisms that are not yet fully understood. These new drugs, along with beloranib—which produces more dramatic weight loss than anything currently available but is still undergoing clinical trials—were discussed with great excitement last month by experts and researchers at the international Obesity Week conference in Atlanta.

But I’ve never prescribed diet drugs, and few doctors in my primary-care practice have, either. Donna Ryan, an obesity specialist at the Pennington Biomedical Research Center at Louisiana State University, has found that only a small percentage of the doctors she has surveyed regularly prescribe any of the drugs currently approved by the F.D.A. Sales figures indicate that physicians haven’t embraced the new medications, Qsymia and Belviq, either.

The inauspicious history of diet drugs no doubt contributes to doctors’ reluctance to prescribe them. In the nineteen-forties, when doctors began prescribing amphetamines for weight loss, rates of addiction soared. Then, in the nineties, fen-phen, a popular combination of fenfluramine and phentermine, was pulled from the market when patients developed serious heart defects. Current medications are much safer, but they produce only modest weight loss, in the range of about five to ten per cent, and they do have side effects.

Still, as Ryan pointed out, doctors aren’t always shy about prescribing medications that cause side effects and yield undramatic results. A five to ten per cent weight loss might not thrill patients, or even nudge them out of being overweight or obese, but it can improve diabetes control, blood pressure, cholesterol, sleep apnea, and other complications of obesity. And, although the drugs aren’t covered by Medicare or most states’ Medicaid programs, private insurance coverage of weight-loss drugs has improved and is likely to expand further under the Affordable Care Act, which requires insurers to pay for obesity treatment. So what prevents physicians from prescribing these drugs?

Several leading experts and researchers attending Obesity Week told me that the problem is that, while specialists who study obesity view it as a chronic but treatable disease, primary-care physicians are not fully convinced that they should be treating obesity at all. Even though physicians since Hippocrates have known that excess body fat can cause diseases, the American Medical Association announced that it would recognize obesity itself as a disease only a few months ago. These divergent views on obesity represent one of the widest gulfs of understanding between generalists and specialists in all of medicine.

Lee M. Kaplan, co-director of the Weight Center at Massachusetts General Hospital, thinks that some bias comes from the average physician’s lack of appreciation for the complex physiology of weight homeostasis. Humans have evolved to avoid starvation rather than obesity, and we defend our body mass through an elaborate system involving the brain, the gut, fat cells, and a network of hormones and neurotransmitters, only a fraction of which have been identified. Obesity, Kaplan said, which represents dysfunction of this system, is likely not one disease but dozens.

That one person’s obesity is not like another’s may explain why some people lose a lot of weight with surgery, or a particular diet or drug, and some don’t. Kaplan thinks that if more doctors understood this, they’d view obesity treatment more receptively and realistically. He said, “If I were to say to you, ‘I have this drug that treats cancer,’ and you asked me, ‘What kind of cancer?,’ and I said, ‘All cancers,’ you’d laugh, because you recognize intuitively that cancer is a heterogeneous group of disorders. We’re going to look back on obesity one day and say the same thing.”

Obesity is potentially, in part, a neurological disease. Jeffrey Flier, an endocrinologist and dean of Harvard Medical School, has shown, like others, that repeatedly eating more calories than you burn can damage the hypothalamus, an area of the brain involved in eating and satiety. In other words, Big Gulps, Cinnabons, and Whoppers have altered our brains such that many people—particularly those with a genetic predisposition to obesity—find fattening foods all but impossible to resist once they’ve eaten enough of them. Louis J. Aronne, director of the Comprehensive Weight Control Program at New York-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center, explained to me, “With so much calorie-dense food available, the hypothalamic neurons get overloaded and the brain can’t tell how much body fat is already stored. The response is to try to store more fat. So there’s very strong scientific evidence that obesity is not about people lacking willpower.”

But this message has not found its way into society, where obese people are still often considered self-indulgent and lazy, and face widespread discrimination. Several obesity experts told me they’ve encountered doctors who confide that they just didn’t like fat people and don’t enjoy taking care of them. Even doctors who treat obese patients feel stigmatized: “diet doctor” is not a flattering term. Donna Ryan, who switched from oncology to obesity medicine many years ago, recalls her colleagues’ surprise. “I had respect,” she says. “I was treating leukemia!”

George Bray, also of the Pennington Biomedical Research Center, thinks that socioeconomic factors play into physicians’ lack of enthusiasm for treating obesity. Bray points to the work of Adam Drewnowski at the University of Washington, who has shown that obesity is, disproportionately, a disease of poverty. Because of this association, many erroneously see obesity as more of a social condition than a medical one, a condition that simply requires people to try harder. Bray said, “If you believe that obesity would be cured if people just pushed themselves away from the table, then why do you want to prescribe drugs for this non-disease, this ‘moral issue’? I think that belief permeates a lot of the medical field.”

Obesity experts with whom I spoke tended to be more optimistic than other physicians about the possibility that obesity can be treated successfully and that the obesity epidemic will be curbed. They point to exciting new research—for example, the finding that an alteration in gut bacteria, rather than mechanical shrinking of the stomach or intestine, may be what causes weight loss after gastric bypass. This raises the possibility that the benefits of surgery might become available without the surgery itself. They also note that public-health efforts seem to be reducing childhood obesity, even in poor communities. But they remain concerned that despite such promising developments, many physicians still don’t see obesity the way they do: as a serious, often preventable disease that requires intensive and lifelong treatment with a combination of diet, exercise, behavioral modification, surgery, and, potentially, drugs.

Louis Aronne thinks this will change as more physicians enter the field of obesity medicine, the physiology of obesity is better understood, and more effective treatment options become available. He likens the current attitude toward obesity to the prevailing attitude toward mental illness years ago. Aronne remembers, during his medical training, seeing psychotic patients warehoused and sedated, treated as less than human. He predicts that, one day, “some doctors are going to look back at severely obese patients and say, ‘What the hell was I thinking when I didn’t do anything to help them? How wrong could I have been?’ ”

Patients like the woman who asked me to help her lose weight may not have to wait that long. Specialists are now developing programs to aid primary-care physicians in treating obesity more aggressively and effectively. But we’ll have to want to treat it: as Kaplan argues, “Whether you call it a disease or not is not so germane. The root problem is that whatever you call it, nobody’s taking it seriously enough.”

Suzanne Koven is a primary-care doctor at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston and writes the column “In Practice” at the Boston Globe.

Photograph by Patrick Allard/REA/Redux.

View Original Article: newyorker.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source newyorker.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Diet Drugs Work: Why..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"a","i":"1335057","t":"Subscriber Services","a":1},{"b":"e","i":"529937","t":"Google's Nest Acquires Smart Home Hub Startup Revolv To Control Every Device In Your Home","a":2},{"b":"a","i":"1335025","t":"Cpl. Cirillo arrives home to Hamilton along the Highway of Heroes","a":3},{"b":"b","i":"1273066","t":"RICO Republicans File Complaint Over Ballot Procedures","a":4},{"b":"b","i":"1273016","t":"Tiny Confirms Permanent Eye Color Change","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1273022","t":"Redmond Rotary participates in World Polio Day","a":6},{"b":"b","i":"1273027","t":"PGA of America statement on Bishop's removal","a":7},{"b":"a","i":"1335003","t":"What We Know About the Washington State High School Shooting Suspect - Yahoo","a":8},{"b":"a","i":"1334997","t":"Around Here briefs","a":9},{"b":"a","i":"1334973","t":"Football: Southside \u2018D\u2019 Facing High-Powered Offense","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1334981","t":"Nadal To Play In Rio Open In 2015","a":11},{"b":"d","i":"959354","t":"Thanks to This Week's Advertisers","a":12},{"b":"c","i":"1883533","t":"Fond, and not-so-fond, remembrances of college football's poll system","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1272989","t":"3 suspects sought in August slaying","a":14},{"b":"a","i":"1334959","t":"Police records show far more blacks than whites shot by local officers","a":15},{"b":"d","i":"959340","t":"Diodes Incorporated to Present at the Wells Fargo Securities Technology, Media and Telecom Conference on November 12","a":16},{"b":"c","i":"1883518","t":"Fond, and not-so-fond, remembrances of college football's poll system","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1272937","t":"Google’s Larry Page Hands More Power to Sundar Pichai","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1272946","t":"Phase 3 Coming To WIU","a":19},{"b":"b","i":"1272951","t":"VIDEO: Maddox family's \"one cow\" philosophy changed industry","a":20},{"b":"f","i":"1157330","t":"NY, NJ announce new Ebola quarantine policy; woman quarantined after Newark landing","a":21},{"b":"a","i":"1334932","t":"Perception vs. Reality: Quicken Loans Announces Two Revolutionary Monthly Indexes","a":22},{"b":"a","i":"1334933","t":"Pizza Inn launches Treats for Troops With a Twist","a":23},{"b":"c","i":"1883508","t":"The Democratic Embrace of Al Sharpton","a":24},{"b":"b","i":"1272910","t":"Dorchester Town vs Bristol Rovers preview: FA Cup has good vibes for Jake Gosling","a":25},{"b":"b","i":"1272920","t":"1st NY Ebola Case Prompts Mandatory Quarantine, Officials Urge Calm","a":26},{"b":"b","i":"1272930","t":"Bristol revenge porn victim sets up website to help others affected by online crime","a":27},{"b":"b","i":"1272899","t":"Hospitality Design","a":28},{"b":"a","i":"1334878","t":"Konerko, Rollins win Clemente Award","a":29},{"b":"f","i":"1157316","t":"Need to Know - Friday October 24, 2014","a":30},{"b":"a","i":"1334873","t":"Featured Brokers","a":31},{"b":"d","i":"959277","t":"MAS flight diverted to Bali after passenger goes into labour","a":32},{"b":"b","i":"1272856","t":"Celebrity Jobs Before They Got Famous","a":33},{"b":"d","i":"959225","t":"Malaysia's Growing Climate of Repression Gets Ignored","a":34},{"b":"a","i":"1334811","t":"Ex-Des Plaines Man Gets 17-1\/2 Years In Murder-For-Hire Plot","a":35},{"b":"b","i":"1272790","t":"Natixis Global Asset Management to purchase NexGen Financial for CA$7.25 per share - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":36},{"b":"c","i":"1883425","t":"Opponent's workers indicted on charges of burning Newark mayor's campaign bus","a":37},{"b":"d","i":"959213","t":"HealthEquity Appoints Matthew Sydney as Executive Vice President, Sales and Marketing","a":38},{"b":"d","i":"959214","t":"Much at stake for Hornets against Tigers","a":39},{"b":"c","i":"1883414","t":"Hillary Clinton Showers Elizabeth Warren With \u2018Love\u2019","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1272775","t":"Episode 400: What Two Pasta Factories Tell Us About The Italian Economy","a":41},{"b":"b","i":"1272781","t":"Dolce & Gabbana Founders Found Innocent in Tax Evasion Case: "We Knew It!!! We Are Honest People!"","a":42},{"b":"a","i":"1334785","t":"Microsoft helps boost US stocks","a":43},{"b":"d","i":"959176","t":"Pain Begins to Spread as China's Home Prices Fall for Fifth Month","a":44},{"b":"c","i":"1883396","t":"Stocks Post Biggest Gains in More Than a Year","a":45},{"b":"b","i":"1272750","t":"APSU Set for International Expansion with $11.2m Investment","a":46},{"b":"e","i":"529903","t":"Google's Nest Acquires Smart Home Hub Startup Revolv To Control Every Device In Your Home","a":47},{"b":"b","i":"1272739","t":"Make the most of the sun before rain appears","a":48},{"b":"g","i":"35377","t":"Watch... Kansas City Royals at San Francisco Giants Game 3 online..Royals v Giants World Series g3 live stream..Guthrie vs. Hudson","a":49},{"b":"b","i":"1272714","t":"College player fights tumor for moment on court","a":50},{"b":"a","i":"1334698","t":"SENATORS: Obama Administration is intentionally misleading Americans on proposed water rule","a":51},{"b":"d","i":"959130","t":"Thanks to This Week's Advertisers","a":52},{"b":"a","i":"1334677","t":"NY & NJ Announce Mandatory 21-Day Ebola Quarantine Policy","a":53},{"b":"a","i":"1334682","t":"WTVC NewsChannel 9 :: News - Top Stories - Ebola 'Poses No Threat to Others,' Mayor Assures New York","a":54},{"b":"a","i":"1334685","t":"Cuomo and Christie Roll Out Mandatory Ebola Quarantine | New York Observer","a":55},{"b":"d","i":"959101","t":"BERNARD HOPKINS AND SERGEY KOVALEV MEDIA CONFERENCE CALL TRANSCRIPT","a":56},{"b":"c","i":"1883353","t":"Read This Before Buying IBM Stock","a":57},{"b":"a","i":"1334631","t":"Study looks at how obesity affects asthma","a":58},{"b":"f","i":"1157271","t":"Heidi Montag Debuts Her Breast Reduction, J.K. Rowling To Publish New Story on Halloween + More in Today's Last Lap","a":59},{"b":"a","i":"1334618","t":"Era Group Inc. Announces Q3 2014 Earnings Release Call","a":60},{"b":"a","i":"1334630","t":"Rules for Trading Leveraged ETFs","a":61},{"b":"d","i":"959056","t":"Alibaba reportedly eying Brazilian acquisition targets","a":62},{"b":"d","i":"959063","t":"Friday's ETF Movers: ILF, GDXJ","a":63},{"b":"d","i":"959068","t":"Queen sends first tweet, signed 'Elizabeth R'","a":64},{"b":"c","i":"1883335","t":"HIT & RUN BLOG","a":65},{"b":"d","i":"959046","t":"Halloween: A howling good time for everyone","a":66},{"b":"b","i":"1272642","t":"New Dad Ryan Gosling Returns to Work (and Grows a Mustache!) After Birth of Baby Girl Esmeralda—See the Pic!","a":67},{"b":"b","i":"1272643","t":"You Can Now Watch A Full Movie On Oculus Rift","a":68},{"b":"e","i":"529850","t":"Two Weeks Out, RGA Reduces Spending Target in Wisconsin?","a":69},{"b":"b","i":"1272621","t":"John Hancock acquires Oracle Tower, 12 story, Class "A" office building in Orange County, California","a":70},{"b":"b","i":"1272622","t":"Independent Agents Endorse Ricketts For Governor","a":71},{"b":"b","i":"1272623","t":"DST Systems, Inc. Declares Cash Dividend","a":72},{"b":"b","i":"1272630","t":"FGIC Announces NYSDFS Approval of CPP Upward Adjustment - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":73},{"b":"d","i":"959023","t":"John Hancock acquires Oracle Tower, 12 story, Class "A" office building in Orange County, California","a":74},{"b":"d","i":"958998","t":"College player fights tumor for moment on court","a":75},{"b":"d","i":"959004","t":"Former 800m world champ Mulaudzi dies","a":76},{"b":"d","i":"958973","t":"Larry Lessig's Mission to Reclaim Democracy","a":77},{"b":"b","i":"1272566","t":"Dicerna to Announce Third-Quarter 2014 Financial Results and Host Conference Call on November 6, 2014 - Yahoo India Finance","a":78},{"b":"a","i":"1334522","t":"Performant Financial Corporation Announces Third Quarter 2014 Earnings Release Date and Teleconference - Yahoo India Finance","a":79},{"b":"a","i":"1334526","t":"Google\u2019s Nest Unit Buys Home-Automation Startup Revolv","a":80},{"b":"d","i":"958959","t":"McCoy Global Inc. Announces Resignation of Vice President, Human Resources Tom Watts","a":81},{"b":"b","i":"1272543","t":"MFDA Hearing Panel adjourns Application Hearing regarding Gilles Latour - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":82},{"b":"b","i":"1272545","t":"College player fights tumor for moment on court","a":83},{"b":"b","i":"1272546","t":"Seabury Group Advises on Successful \u20a4125 Million Recapitalization and Sale of Monarch Airlines Group to Greybull Capital - Yahoo India Finance","a":84},{"b":"b","i":"1272558","t":"Capital Power Reports Third Quarter 2014 Results","a":85},{"b":"e","i":"529799","t":"Jim Parsons leads voice cast for NBC's 'Elf' stop-motion animated special","a":86},{"b":"f","i":"1157199","t":"'Avengers: Age Of Ultron' Trailer Smashes Viewing Record; More Footage Coming","a":87},{"b":"c","i":"1883285","t":"90 percent of Americans are poorer today than in 1987","a":88},{"b":"a","i":"1334454","t":"New Jersey decision expected today on sports betting challenge - RGT Online","a":89},{"b":"d","i":"958936","t":"General Says N. Korea May Have Know-How for Small Warhead","a":90},{"b":"d","i":"958939","t":"Prasad finds clues to promote Ayodhya in Korean history","a":91},{"b":"a","i":"1334445","t":"Reformer Gough Whitlam oversaw economic chaos but it was not all of Labor's making","a":92},{"b":"a","i":"1334448","t":"Infinite Monkeys Names Bloomingdale High School as Mobile App Of The Week for October 12th-18th","a":93},{"b":"a","i":"1334416","t":"Coordinated Health "I'm Good" and "Show Us Your School Pride" Programs Celebrate Both the Student Athlete and "Athlete Within"\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tTV campaign features five schools and 13 teams from Greater Lehigh Valley","a":94},{"b":"e","i":"529765","t":"Dear God, Please Don't Dress Up For Halloween","a":95},{"b":"f","i":"1156977","t":"Person In Panda Suit Makes Appearance At Congressional Wannabe's City Hall Press Conference","a":96},{"b":"f","i":"1156976","t":"Full Timeline Of Ebola Patient's Movements Around NYC","a":97},{"b":"a","i":"1334384","t":"Case dropped against teen accused of posting offensive tweets about tragic Newcastle United fans","a":98},{"b":"c","i":"1883236","t":"Violet Township trustee convicted of accidentally shooting student in concealed-carry class","a":99},{"b":"d","i":"958878","t":"'Premature' to talk of US troop cuts in Asia: John Kerry","a":100}]

      100

      Subscriber Services