English | Italian

"Stocks' rising tide floats..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

show list
related videos
Households preferred to save rather than spend during Q2 - BOK 2분기 가계 자금잉여 30조
HOMES NEPAL " Bishnumati River Cleaning Campaign Part 1 "
HOMES NEPAL " Bishnumati River Cleaning Campaign Part 2 "
Green Calgary ~ Urban Environmental Organization - Healthy Homes/Communities Education
The Experts Talk: Contacts, Organizations, Households and Headaches! by Now IT Matters
Controlling Who Gets a Household in the Nonprofit Starter Pack
Continue »
Pop theme

Andy Murray,Republican Party,Ebola Virus,Virgin Galactic,Tim Cook,Ukraine gas,Bank of Japan,Andy Murray,Peshmerga,Blaise Compaore

Related theme

Stocks' rising tide floats some boats higher than others

nonprofit organizations households

2014-02-28 12:12:34

We can learn a lot from anniversaries. Consider, if you will, the upcoming fifth anniversary of the bottom of the stock market, which hit its low on Mar. 9, 2009 as share prices plummeted and many holders ran screaming for the exit as predictions of the end of financial and investment life as we had known it filled the air.

Since then, U.S. stocks have almost tripled in value, according to the Wilshire 5000 index, the best measure of the total U.S. market. The value of Americans' home equity is up sharply, too—but nowhere near as much as stocks have risen. And thereby hangs a little-noticed tale of how people at or near the top of the economic food chain have profited substantially more from the stock and housing rebounds than other people have.

    No results related

    Add now

No, this isn't a screed about the evils, real and imagined, of income and wealth inequality. I'm just telling you what the numbers showed me when I decided to compare the rebound in homeowners' equity, which is the biggest source of wealth for broad swatches of Americans, with the rebound of stocks, which is the biggest source of wealth for only a relatively small handful of Americans, primarily those with high net worths. And, I assume, high incomes.

My wealth numbers come from the Federal Reserve's surveys of households' net worth. I've tweaked some of the Fed's statistics, which it releases quarterly, to estimate values for stocks on Market Bottom Day in 2009, and for stocks and home equity today. (You can find my methodology at the bottom of this column.)

The Fed excludes mutual funds and retirement accounts from its stock numbers, and I don't think that including them would change the numbers in any meaningful way, given how concentrated stock ownership is. For example, economist Robert Frank of Cornell estimates that 5% of Americans own 60% of all individual stocks.

And here we go.

When last I looked, the Wilshire 5000—the broadest measure of the U.S. stock market—was up about 190% from the bottom. During the same five-year period, the value of home equity has risen by about 40%. That's about $3 trillion, which isn't chopped liver. But it's little more than a third as much as the $8.8 trillion increase in Americans' holdings of stocks (as we're measuring them here).

Five years ago, at the stock market bottom, home equity, at $7.4 trillion, substantially exceeded the value of stocks owned by individuals ($4.4 trillion). Now, stocks are about $13.2 trillion, compared with $10.4 trillion of home equity.

After bottoming on Mar. 9, 2009, stocks roared up—by the end of the month, they had risen about 18%--and have pretty much kept going. Meanwhile, home equity  kept drifting down until the middle of 2012, when it finally turned upward.

Stocks have set one new high after another, while home equity is still down from its peak of $12.5 trillion in 2005. At the time, stocks were $8 trillion, about 65% of home equity. Now, stocks are more than 125% of home equity.

The bottom line: The rising tide in stocks and home equity is floating all boats—but the boats with lots of stocks in them are floating higher a lot quicker.

Where my numbers come from:


On Mar. 9, 2009, the Wilshire 5000 closed at 84.5% of its value on Mar. 30 of that year. So I subtracted 15% from the Fed's Mar. 30, 2009 stock ownership number to come up with a Mar. 9 number.

Similarly, I compared the Wilshire's value in late February with its value on Sept. 30, 2013, the date of the most recent Fed numbers. The Wilshire has risen about 10% since Sept. 30, so I added about 10% to the Fed's Sept. 30 number.

(I didn't take net purchases and sales of stocks, as reported by the Fed, into account; there are only so many numbers I can cope with without having my head explode.)

The Fed numbers include Americans' holdings of both U.S. and foreign stocks, while the Wilshire measures only U.S. stocks. But I doubt that a more elaborate estimation method than my simplistic use of the Wilshire 5000 would make a substantial difference in the findings.

House equity:

I used the Fed's Mar. 30, 2009 number as my starting point, because I have no idea how to estimate home equity value three weeks earlier. I came up with my current estimate for home equity by taking the Sept. 30, 2013 number, adding $700 billion, and rounding up. That $700 billion assumes that home equity has continued rising since last Sept. 30 at the same monthly rate that it increased between June 30 and Sept. 30.

My stock and equity numbers come from two lines--corporate equities, and owners' equity in household real estate—in the Fed's Balance Sheet of Households and Nonprofit Organizations.

View Original Article: Fortune
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source Fortune.
Or contact us


Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Stocks' rising tide floats..." IN THE COMMUNITY!



        No results related
      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"f","i":"1175678","t":"Hilton HHonors Members Earn Double Points After Voting on Year-End Promotion","a":1},{"b":"f","i":"1175674","t":"The Est\u00e9e Lauder Companies Acquires RODIN olio lusso","a":2},{"b":"f","i":"1175673","t":"Hilton Worldwide Signs Exclusive License Agreement for Major Expansion of Hampton by Hilton Hotels in China","a":3},{"b":"f","i":"1175681","t":"General Cable Reports Third Quarter Results; Announces Plan to Exit Asia Pacific and Africa; Plans Leadership Transition","a":4},{"b":"f","i":"1175620","t":"General Cable Reports Third Quarter Results; Announces Plan to Exit Asia Pacific and Africa; Plans Leadership Transition","a":5},{"b":"f","i":"1175617","t":"Hilton HHonors Members Earn Double Points After Voting on Year-End Promotion","a":6},{"b":"f","i":"1175613","t":"The Est\u00e9e Lauder Companies Acquires RODIN olio lusso","a":7},{"b":"f","i":"1175612","t":"Hilton Worldwide Signs Exclusive License Agreement for Major Expansion of Hampton by Hilton Hotels in China","a":8},{"b":"b","i":"1300381","t":"Refugee program worries locals","a":9},{"b":"b","i":"1300386","t":"ATF Jet fuel prices slashed by 7.3 per cent","a":10},{"b":"a","i":"1363784","t":"The Berlin Wall fell 25 years ago, but Germany is still divided « Demi Rakyat","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1300347","t":"All Malaysian MH17 victims accounted for, says Hisham - Yahoo News Singapore","a":12},{"b":"f","i":"1175698","t":"Crash a 'major delay' to space plan","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1300354","t":"Agents, lenders fill niche as Chinese money floods housing market","a":14},{"b":"b","i":"1300359","t":"NBA scores: The Cavaliers rebound in Chicago and three other things we learned on Halloween","a":15},{"b":"b","i":"1300312","t":"Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo Crash: Experts React","a":16},{"b":"d","i":"978773","t":"Advance historic page from April 11, 1970: 'For and about women'","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1300300","t":"Columbus Crew vs. New England Revolution, 2014 MLS Playoffs: Upstarts looking to make a run","a":18},{"b":"f","i":"1175700","t":"A 'hard,' deadly day for space tourism","a":19},{"b":"a","i":"1363742","t":"TN Promise Program Application Deadline Is Today","a":20},{"b":"d","i":"978767","t":"Openshaw shooting: Pragaret Singh gunned down in robbery as he locked up family firm Manchester Food Traders","a":21},{"b":"f","i":"1175737","t":"One Direction Tickets in Minneapolis, Minnesota (MN) @ TCF Bank Stadium On Sale Today For 2015 'On The Road Again' Tour.","a":22},{"b":"a","i":"1363722","t":"iWallet At CES 2015: Company To Showcase Portfolio Of Secure, Carbon Fiber Luxury Techcessories At World's Largest Consumer Technology Show","a":23},{"b":"a","i":"1363724","t":"NXP SmartMX2 Card Platform Achieves Highest Level Of Security For MIFARE Applications","a":24},{"b":"b","i":"1300287","t":"40 North launches CSA for art","a":25},{"b":"a","i":"1363690","t":"Murals add an artistic touch to home decor","a":26},{"b":"a","i":"1363692","t":"Area history, Nov. 1, 2014","a":27},{"b":"d","i":"978716","t":"KL Rahul's twin tons take South Zone closer to title","a":28},{"b":"b","i":"1300273","t":"Marine Reservist Jailed in Mexico Back on US Soil - Yahoo","a":29},{"b":"d","i":"978698","t":"Pakistan police arrest 2 suspects involved in Benazir Bhutto attack case","a":30},{"b":"c","i":"1897708","t":"Marine Reservist Jailed in Mexico Back on US Soil","a":31},{"b":"b","i":"1300237","t":"Champs Caribs face Harvard in knockout final","a":32},{"b":"f","i":"1175704","t":"Eye Opener: Disaster for Virgin Galactic","a":33},{"b":"a","i":"1363630","t":"Winter won't go away, but Winnipegers can - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":34},{"b":"a","i":"1363633","t":"High School Teams Receive Lemelson-MIT InvenTeam Grant For Invention Projects","a":35},{"b":"a","i":"1363634","t":"e-SignLive By Silanis Increases Productivity For Microsoft SharePoint Users By Keeping Business Digital With E-Signatures","a":36},{"b":"f","i":"1175742","t":"Temperature-Monitoring Technologies Are Solving Food Spoilage Dilemmas","a":37},{"b":"f","i":"1175585","t":"Today In History, November 1","a":38},{"b":"d","i":"978654","t":"Ukraine Today: New Kremlin infowar victim; The Moscow Times halts online comments after surge in offensive remarks ...","a":39},{"b":"d","i":"978652","t":"Violence Flares in Ferguson After Fire at Brown Memorial: Reports","a":40},{"b":"f","i":"1175588","t":"Ex-Sunderland star Gyan's statement on ritual sacrifice allegations","a":41},{"b":"b","i":"1300220","t":"The future of cars today: What's driving new technology","a":42},{"b":"b","i":"1300206","t":"Roads and Transport Authority launches virtual tram - Yahoo Maktoob News","a":43},{"b":"d","i":"978635","t":"Manish Malhotra celebrates a year of Delhi store","a":44},{"b":"a","i":"1363605","t":"Australia, New Zealand mark 100 years since first troops left for World War I","a":45},{"b":"c","i":"1897670","t":"Spaceship crash shakes desert town","a":46},{"b":"b","i":"1300186","t":"U.K.-Based Impero Unveils U.S. Expansion Plans, Determined To Help Schools And Students Maximize Technology In The Classroom","a":47},{"b":"a","i":"1363576","t":"Power blackout hits Bangladesh as transmission line from India fails","a":48},{"b":"d","i":"978603","t":"Hello Kitty Celebrates 40th Birthday","a":49},{"b":"a","i":"1363580","t":"Today in Westport: 11-01-14 - Westport News","a":50},{"b":"a","i":"1363585","t":"Water charge protests underway as tens of thousands due on streets","a":51},{"b":"d","i":"978622","t":"Fast and Furious 7: Watch Paul Walker's Last Movie 'Furious 7' Trailer Live Stream Online","a":52},{"b":"c","i":"1897662","t":"6 housing boomtowns that haven't come back","a":53},{"b":"d","i":"978599","t":"The investments that pay an\u00a0inflation-beating income","a":54},{"b":"b","i":"1300159","t":"Stafford fireworks factory fire: Searches resume at site where two bodies found","a":55},{"b":"b","i":"1300171","t":"Ajay Devgn is co-owner of Delhi franchise in Vijay Amritraj-backed Champions Tennis League","a":56},{"b":"f","i":"1175592","t":"Pecan Festival forecast still calls for fun","a":57},{"b":"b","i":"1300148","t":"It’s time for new student activism, says Kit Siang","a":58},{"b":"f","i":"1175593","t":"Good morning -- 12 things to do today","a":59},{"b":"c","i":"1897644","t":"Now that the Nexus 6 isn’t cheap, is it worth buying at all?","a":60},{"b":"d","i":"978570","t":"President Mukhrjee extends greetings on Durga Puja","a":61},{"b":"d","i":"978545","t":"Petrobras Said to Skip Fuel Price Discussion at Board Meeting","a":62},{"b":"b","i":"1300115","t":"Corsets to send you all a-Quiver as new theatrical-themed store opens in Cambridge","a":63},{"b":"d","i":"978516","t":"Hrithik Roshan, Sussanne Khan granted divorce; 14-year-old marriage legally comes to an end","a":64},{"b":"f","i":"1175452","t":"Today's best bets around Siouxland","a":65},{"b":"f","i":"1175459","t":"Scotland would vote yes to independence today, poll finds","a":66},{"b":"f","i":"1175461","t":"Malaysia Cup final: Festive atmosphere in Bukit Jalil","a":67},{"b":"f","i":"1175467","t":"Watch: Aaron Harber discusses Amendment 67: Personhood","a":68},{"b":"f","i":"1175468","t":"'TOWIE' Star James 'Arg' Argent Suspended From Show 'After Positive Cocaine Test'","a":69},{"b":"b","i":"1300098","t":"Toyota Kirloskar sales down 12% in October | Business Standard News","a":70},{"b":"b","i":"1300081","t":"Weather cannot dampen Derby Day","a":71},{"b":"d","i":"978477","t":"Japan Rolls The Dice: A Report From Tokyo","a":72},{"b":"a","i":"1363388","t":"Ballots missing in Powell reappear","a":73},{"b":"b","i":"1300049","t":"RT\u00c9 TEN TV picks for today Friday Oct 31","a":74},{"b":"a","i":"1363372","t":"Heatwave to ease a little, but leave your jumper at home","a":75},{"b":"b","i":"1300039","t":"Hrithik, Sussanne now legally divorced","a":76},{"b":"a","i":"1363348","t":"Hyundai sales up 12% in October, exports up 27% | Business Standard News","a":77},{"b":"a","i":"1363366","t":"Hyundai Motor sales up 11.5% in Oct","a":78},{"b":"d","i":"978412","t":"Czech life expectancy today markedly higher than before Velvet Revolution","a":79},{"b":"a","i":"1363316","t":"IT capital Bangalore is now Bengaluru","a":80},{"b":"a","i":"1363321","t":"Burkina Faso Must End Excessive Use of Force Against Protesters","a":81},{"b":"a","i":"1363294","t":"BRUSSELS NOTEBOOK: Transition weekend in Brussels","a":82},{"b":"a","i":"1363302","t":"Craig Gordon reveals he owes Rangers a debt of gratitude for helping him resurrect his career at Celtic","a":83},{"b":"d","i":"978404","t":"Mainland education expo opens","a":84},{"b":"f","i":"1175565","t":"ME-Newswire: Hilton HHonors Members Earn Double Points After Voting on Year-End Promotion","a":85},{"b":"b","i":"1300000","t":"Will the Internet of Things Become a Big Waste?","a":86},{"b":"g","i":"41195","t":"Madhav Web Hosting India Introduces Reliable & Secure Web Hosting Solutions at Affordable Prices","a":87},{"b":"f","i":"1175568","t":"ME-Newswire: Hilton Worldwide Signs Exclusive License Agreement for Major Expansion of Hampton by Hilton Hotels in China","a":88},{"b":"d","i":"978364","t":"Wine & Spirits Distribution Industry Leader Martignetti Ditches Laptops for Sturdy, Flexible Mobile Sales Solution on ...","a":89},{"b":"f","i":"1175391","t":"New US general seeks China air safety dialogue","a":90},{"b":"a","i":"1363257","t":"Florida\u2019s Muschamp gets another shot at alma mater | News Tribune","a":91},{"b":"d","i":"978346","t":"This Week in Politics: Cuomo, Christie Bet the Farm","a":92},{"b":"d","i":"978355","t":"OKC's Westbrook suffers hand fracture","a":93},{"b":"f","i":"1175572","t":"ME-Newswire: The Est\u00e9e Lauder Companies Acquires RODIN olio lusso","a":94},{"b":"f","i":"1175394","t":"Astrological Forecasts for 11\/01\/2014","a":95},{"b":"f","i":"1175395","t":"Selangor Umno needs reforms to recapture state: Najib","a":96},{"b":"b","i":"1299954","t":"Greens to introduce Publish What You Pay Bill","a":97},{"b":"a","i":"1363224","t":"China completes first return mission to moon","a":98},{"b":"d","i":"978289","t":"More than \u00a33.5 million worth of property sold at auction today in Norwich","a":99},{"b":"f","i":"1175396","t":"SR Geek Picks: Best Horror Comics, Upcoming Superhero Movie Infographic & More","a":100}]


      Hilton HHonors Members Earn Double Points After Voting on Year-End Promotion