English | Italian

"Obama in Asia: Washington..." (Theme) The lastest total: 100+. you can read with page flip.

close
show list
related videos
President Xi: Efforts needed to make China a cyber power
CONSTRUCTIVES - 28 June 2011
What Will Happen to Chen's Calls for Investigation [©NTDTV]
5176AS THAILAND-ASEAN SOUTH CHINA SEA
Questions Arise over North Koreas Nuclear Capability
CCTV video surveillance on mobile phone TeleEye Mobile Monitoring Solution Version 2 YouTube
Continue »
Pop theme

Scottish independence,Taliban,David Haines,Alex Salmond,Alan Pardew,California Fire,Kanye West,Jessica Simpson,Django Unchained,Danny Welbeck

Related theme

cold war,russia

Obama in Asia: Washington Extracts Rent-Free Basing From the Philippines | The Nation


philippines security beijing

2014-04-30 18:30:10

President Barack Obama speaks to troops in Manila, April 29, 2014. (Reuters/Larry Downing)

This article is a joint publication of TheNation.com and Foreign Policy In Focus.

 

As US President Barack Obama descended on the Philippines, Manila and Washington were rushing to complete negotiations on an Agreement on Enhanced Defense Cooperation (AEDC) between the two countries.

The Philippines’ territorial disputes with China are one major reason for this new agreement. With Washington’s help, Philippine President Benigno Aquino III wants to make the Chinese respect the Philippines’ claims in the Scarborough Shoal, the Spratly Islands, the continental shelf and its 200-mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ).

The truth of the matter, however, is that the deal will do no such thing.

What the agreement boils

down to is that the Philippines will give the United States the right to operate bases in the country—for no rent—without the guarantee of US protection of the Philippines' island territories.

A Raw Deal

According to Philippine officials, the new agreement is governed by the US-Philippine Mutual Defense Treaty (MDT), which they say obliges Washington to come to the Philippines’ defense in the event of an attack on Philippine territory, including its possessions in the West Philippine Sea. Here they cite Article V of the MDT, which says “an armed attack on either of the Parties is deemed to include an armed attack on the metropolitan territory of either of the Parties, or on the island territories under its jurisdiction in the Pacific, or on its armed forces, public vessels, or aircraft in the Pacific.”

That is not the way the United States sees it. Indeed, the US government has not deviated from the position explicitly stated several years ago by Morton Smith, a US Embassy spokesperson. According to researcher Roland San Juan, Smith asserted that the Spratly Islands claimed by the Philippines are excluded from the scope of the treaty because the Philippines raised its claim to them more than three decades after the MDT was signed in 1951.

This is in contrast to Washington’s implicit support for Japan in its territorial dispute with China over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands. “I restated the principles that govern longstanding US policy on the Senkaku Islands and other islands,” US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said of his April visit to Beijing. “We affirmed that since [the Senkaku Islands] are under Japan’s administrative control, they fall under Article 5 of our Mutual Security Treaty.” Article V of the US-Japan Mutual Security Treaty provides that “an armed attack against either Party in the territories under the administration of Japan would be dangerous to its own peace and safety and declares that it would act to meet the common danger in accordance with its constitutional provisions and processes.”

During his recent state visit in Japan, Obama reiterated this commitment to Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. But he will not make the same promise to President Aquino in Manila when it comes to the Philippine possessions in the South China Sea.

Unlike the Scarborough Shoal and the Spratly Islands claimed by the Philippines, the Senkakus were under the administrative control of the prefecture of Okinawa when the US-Japan Mutual Security Treaty was signed and were thus covered by the restoration of Okinawa to Japan’s control in 1972. “At first glance,” said former Rear Admiral Michael McDevitt, “the disputes China has with the Philippines over Scarborough Shoal in the SCS [South China Sea] appear similar to the ECS [East China Sea] with Japan because the US is a treaty ally of the Philippines. Actually, however, the two situations are different. In the case of Scarborough Shoal, the Philippines did not have undisputed 'administrative control' prior to the 2012 confrontation over the islet. Second, the US is not directly involved in the Scarborough Shoal dispute because its mutual defense treaty with the Philippines does not obligate Washington to take sides over sovereignty questions.”

If the deal does not provide for US support for the Philippines’ territorial claims in the South China Sea, then what’s in it for the Philippines? Most likely an increase in military aid, including a few antiquated Hamilton class cutters. If so, this is a very poor return for a larger US military presence and a grant to operate US bases out of Philippine installations. This is essentially what the deal is all about, though given local sensitivities and a constitutional ban on foreign bases in the Philippines, both parties studiously refrain from calling the concentration of US personnel, facilities and war equipment “bases.”

Pacific Pivot on the Cheap

So what’s in it for the United States?

The US government has always said that its main interest in the South China Sea is “ensuring freedom of navigation.” The first thing to note here is that although China claims the South China Sea as a domestic waterway in its notorious Nine-Dash-Line claim, the threat of its interfering with freedom of navigation has always been remote. China is not about to court world condemnation by enforcing its domestic shipping regulations on a busy waterway through which an estimated one-third of international trade passes. Nor does it have the capability to do so, and won’t for a long time to come.

But even if the Chinese were to pose a threat to international navigation, the United States would not need a Philippine outpost to accomplish its stated goal of protecting international shipping. Even after Washington lost its Philippine bases at the end of the Cold War, the Pentagon had the South China Sea firmly under control throughout the 1990s. According to analyst William Berry, during the Mischief Reef crisis in 1995, then Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs Joseph Nye “stated that if any conflict in the South China Sea threatens freedom of the seas, then the United States Seventh Fleet was prepared to provide escort services so that freedom of navigation could be protected.” That this was no bluff was revealed in 1996 during the Taiwan Straits crisis, when two aircraft carrier battle groups were deployed swiftly and with ease out of Yokosuka, Japan, to show Washington’s support for Taiwan. And again in 1998, a US carrier battle group was sent near the Spratlys, apparently to send a message to all parties that the United States would protect freedom of navigation in international waters, once again showing its ability to act without relying on a base in the Philippines for logistics. Indeed, the elimination of the Subic and Clark bases in the Philippines was probably a big plus for the US Treasury, since it did away with the great cost of maintaining large fixed bases.

So why does the United States now want a higher military profile in the Philippines? The answer lies in what one might call Washington’s “exhibitionist syndrome”—that is, the imperative it feels to “show the flag” to its allies and to China. And if it can do so in an inexpensive way, with a quid pro quo involving just a few of what the Americans call “Excess Defense Articles” like antiquated cutters, then all the better. This is what John Feffer characterizes as Pacific Pivot on the cheap. As Frank Chang of the Foreign Policy Research Institute writes, “It clearly offers the United States a cost-effective way to enhance its presence in Asia, something that Washington has wanted to do for a long time.”

But for the Philippines, the increase in obsolete military donations from Washington will be more than offset by the negative strategic consequences. First of all, the coming agreement will draw the Philippines farther away from a resolution of its territorial disputes with China, and it will be marginalized by the dynamics of a superpower conflict. Second, it will turn the Philippines into another of Washington’s “frontline states” like Afghanistan and Pakistan, with all the detrimental and destabilizing effects such a status entails—including the subordination of the country’s economic, social and cultural dynamics to Washington’s security needs. Third, it will move the region farther away from the negotiation of a collective security agreement, which is a far better alternative to volatile balance-of-power politics, where a simple thing like a ship collision can lead to a bigger conflict.

From Balance of Power to Collective Security

The Philippines’ territorial conflicts with China are real, but the way to resolve them is to rely on international law and diplomacy, and this is terrain in which the Philippines has a big advantage. The Philippines’ submission of a 1,000-page “memorial” delineating the country’s entitlements in the West Philippine Sea to the United Nations Arbitral Tribunal at the end of March was a giant step in this direction. Beijing knows it does not have a leg to stand on in international law, which is why it has been pushing the Philippines to drop the case on pain of “damaging bilateral relations.”

The Philippines must maximize its diplomatic options as well, where it also has an advantage over Beijing. It must press its ASEAN partners to remind Beijing of China’s commitment to negotiate a binding code of conduct on maritime behavior in the West Philippine Sea, which it made at a foreign ministers’ meeting in Brunei in June 2013. It was pressure from ASEAN and internationally that forced Beijing to make this commitment, and it will be consistent pressure that will force it to follow through.

The Philippines should also prepare the ground at the United Nations General Assembly for the eventual introduction of a resolution condemning Beijing’s unilateral annexation of over 80 percent of the South China Sea, brusquely disregarding other littoral states’ rights to their continental shelves and 200-mile EEZs. There’s a very good recent precedent: Beijing’s aggressive annexationism is essentially similar to Russia’s gobbling up of Crimea, which the General Assembly condemned a few weeks ago.

Please support our journalism. Get a digital subscription for just $9.50!

The strategic aim of these diplomatic efforts must be to bring about a collective security agreement for the region that would include ASEAN, Japan, the two Koreas and China. The ASEAN Regional Forum was headed in this direction in the 1990s, despite the opposition of the United States, which arrogated unto itself the role of enforcer of stability in the region. Its momentum was unfortunately derailed by the Asian financial crisis in 1997, which swept the rug from under the credibility of ASEAN’s major states. Although the process will be difficult, it is time to revive this project of collective security, since the unstable and volatile balance-of-power politics favored by Washington is not a viable mechanism for regional peace and security.

With the impending basing agreement with the United States, the Philippines is headed right back to its position during the Cold War, when it played the role of handmaiden to the US containment strategy by hosting two huge military bases. The small window of opportunity to forge an independent foreign policy that the Philippines gained with the expulsion of the US bases in 1992 will disappear with this latest pact with Washington.

Read Next: Katrina vanden Heuvel and Stephen F. Cohen on the new Cold War against Russia.

View Original Article: thenation.com
Disclaimer statement: The point of this article or rights belongs to the authors and publishers. We take no responsibility for the content of this article and legitimacy.
Do you have any questions about this article, please contact the news source thenation.com.
Or contact us

Share

Write an article relevant this topic share on facebook share on twitter share on google plus share on oknews share on linkedin share on digg share on reddit share on newsvine share on pinterest share on netlog share on tumblr share on delicious send email print add to favorite

"Obama in Asia: Washington..." IN THE COMMUNITY!

Facebook
    Twitter

      PHOTO

      Share one Sentence

      Manage my submission

      [{"b":"b","i":"1196709","t":"Bruker Introduces New Products for Preclinical Imaging at WMIC 2014 - Yahoo Finance UK","a":1},{"b":"b","i":"1196712","t":"DuPont Protection Technologies Announces Winners of DuPont\u2122 Kevlar® Glove Innovation Awards","a":2},{"b":"b","i":"1196720","t":"Blue Earth to Purchase Equity Position in PowerGenix With $10 Million Dollar Investment - Yahoo Finance UK","a":3},{"b":"b","i":"1196721","t":"Bullfrog Power and SolarShare Launch Brampton's First Community-Owned Solar Project","a":4},{"b":"b","i":"1196726","t":"Global Hemp Group Partners With Mali's National Agricultural Research Institute on Hemp Research","a":5},{"b":"b","i":"1196690","t":"Autobytel Board Approves Increase in Stock Buy-Back Authorization to $3.0 Million - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":6},{"b":"b","i":"1196691","t":"True North Apartment REIT to be added to S&P\/TSX SmallCap Index","a":7},{"b":"b","i":"1196697","t":"New Manufacturing Facility, Special Meeting Updates, Recognition, Technical Updates, and Clinical Data - Research Reports on Valeant, Allergan, Isis, Regeneron and Teva\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tEditor Note: For more information about this release, please scroll t","a":8},{"b":"b","i":"1196699","t":"Prince Edward Island Scots among Maritimers tuned into independence vote - Regional - The Spectator","a":9},{"b":"b","i":"1196701","t":"Trecora Resources to Present at Singular Research's 9th Annual "Best of the Uncovereds" Conference on September 22, 2014","a":10},{"b":"c","i":"1814282","t":"Salda\u00f1a confirmation hearing to open on friendly note, despite rancor on immigration","a":11},{"b":"b","i":"1196669","t":"Cowboy cap guns","a":12},{"b":"b","i":"1196679","t":"Asuragen\u2019s Xpansion Interpreter\u00ae Test Study of 1,040 Transmissions of Fragile X Alleles Reveals\u00a0Personalized Risks for Expansion from Parent to Child - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":13},{"b":"b","i":"1196685","t":"Hope Interest-Rates Will Rise Slowly: Ratner","a":14},{"b":"b","i":"1196651","t":"Campaigns race for votes on Scottish referendum eve","a":15},{"b":"b","i":"1196656","t":"Global Strategic Communications Company RLM Finsbury to Rebrand as Finsbury - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":16},{"b":"b","i":"1196657","t":"Prince Edward Island Scots among Maritimers tuned into independence vote - Regional - The Vanguard","a":17},{"b":"b","i":"1196666","t":"Relayware Adds Paul Brennan as Newest Member of the Board\r\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tPaul Brennan contributes years of business experience to Relayware and its mission to meet growing demand for partnering automation software","a":18},{"b":"b","i":"1196668","t":"GuruFocus Premium Membership","a":19},{"b":"d","i":"857604","t":"Ukraine's Poroshenko to address Canadian Parliament, meet PM","a":20},{"b":"f","i":"1069274","t":"Eagles live chat: Join us at 12 p.m. today","a":21},{"b":"b","i":"1196643","t":"In pictures: Our picture editor selects the best images from around the globe, September 17","a":22},{"b":"b","i":"1196634","t":"Ukraine's Petro Poroshenko speaks to Parliament, meets PM","a":23},{"b":"d","i":"857539","t":"Salmond assures 'common-sense' currency agreement","a":24},{"b":"d","i":"857540","t":"Darling warns 'no going back' if Yes referendum result","a":25},{"b":"b","i":"1196597","t":"12 Angry Jurors wraps up successful run","a":26},{"b":"b","i":"1196614","t":"Telling the tale of civil rights","a":27},{"b":"f","i":"1069306","t":"What you need to know: Wednesday","a":28},{"b":"b","i":"1196584","t":"Ekso(TM) Clear Leader in Exoskeleton Comparison Study Presented at The International Workshop on Wearable Robotics - Yahoo India Finance","a":29},{"b":"f","i":"1069194","t":"Wonkblog: Wonkbook: The most important \u2014 and disappointing \u2014 aspect of today's economy","a":30},{"b":"c","i":"1814244","t":"Goldfinger: The Man With the Kosher Deli Meat","a":31},{"b":"c","i":"1814247","t":"FedEx Risses as Buyback-Aided Profit Tops Estimates","a":32},{"b":"c","i":"1814249","t":"TV Host Meredith Vieira Opens Up About Why She Stayed In An Abusive Relationship","a":33},{"b":"c","i":"1814251","t":"Air France Drops More Than Half of Flights During Strike","a":34},{"b":"g","i":"23142","t":"NeoSleeve iPhone 5 Running Arm Band Free Shipping Promotion","a":35},{"b":"f","i":"1069340","t":"Here's A Quick Guide To What Traders Are Chatting About Right Now","a":36},{"b":"b","i":"1196557","t":"Atlantic Broadband First to Deliver 1 Gigabit Internet Service in the Greater Miami Area - Yahoo Finance UK","a":37},{"b":"b","i":"1196530","t":"How ‘magic mushroom’ chemical could free the mind of depression, addictions","a":38},{"b":"b","i":"1196532","t":"Champions Oncology Partners with Sarcoma Alliance to Bring Personalized Treatment Options to Sarcoma Patients","a":39},{"b":"b","i":"1196533","t":"Florida Buds Supports Silver Tour","a":40},{"b":"b","i":"1196539","t":"PTC Therapeutics Expands Global Presence in Support of Translarna\u2122 Launch in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy - Yahoo Finance Canada","a":41},{"b":"b","i":"1196540","t":"Catalent, Inc. to Present at the Deutsche Bank 2014 Leveraged Finance Conference - Yahoo Finance UK","a":42},{"b":"c","i":"1814224","t":"READ IN: Dempsey’s Day Edition","a":43},{"b":"d","i":"857499","t":"Round II: Another top teacher explains more of jargon you hate","a":44},{"b":"d","i":"857503","t":"Cancer Geneticist, Alberto Bardelli, Ph.D., Joins Trovagene's Scientific Advisory Board","a":45},{"b":"d","i":"857504","t":"Infor Announces Internship and Educational Alliance Programs","a":46},{"b":"d","i":"857505","t":"CSOFT Launches Blossary.com","a":47},{"b":"b","i":"1196524","t":"Cambridge Engineered Solutions Expands Operations To Five Countries","a":48},{"b":"d","i":"857482","t":"Huron Consulting Group Named a 2014 Top Workplace by The Oregonian","a":49},{"b":"d","i":"857447","t":"Bat at Wimberley school tests positive for rabies","a":50},{"b":"d","i":"857406","t":"2014-15 Is Make-or-Break Year for Detroit Pistons' Brandon Jennings","a":51},{"b":"c","i":"1814185","t":"Featured Stories","a":52},{"b":"f","i":"1069089","t":"FedEx Corp. Earnings Surge in the First Quarter","a":53},{"b":"d","i":"857355","t":"Kanye West Unleashes Rant Against The Media","a":54},{"b":"d","i":"857366","t":"Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott says his visit to India strengthened strategic ties","a":55},{"b":"e","i":"502307","t":"Who Wants $400,000: Steve Case and Forbes Are Investing in the Best Entrepreneurs Under 30","a":56},{"b":"d","i":"857345","t":"ICC Cricket World Cup Trophy Visits Pakistan","a":57},{"b":"d","i":"857317","t":"Comverse Unveils Digital Lifestyle Solutions at PT\/EXPO COMM CHINA","a":58},{"b":"d","i":"857323","t":"Jaycee Chan arrested for harbouring drug users","a":59},{"b":"c","i":"1814117","t":"Apple iOS 8 Available Ahead Of iPhone Release","a":60},{"b":"d","i":"857271","t":"Our Membership Solutions","a":61},{"b":"d","i":"857240","t":"Former Assam Director General of Police Shankar Barua commits suicide","a":62},{"b":"d","i":"857241","t":"Saradha scam: Ex-Assam DGP Sankar Barua, quizzed by CBI, found dead","a":63},{"b":"d","i":"857245","t":"Saradha scam fallout? Assam's ex-DGP commits suicide","a":64},{"b":"d","i":"857247","t":"Former Assam DGP Sankar Barua, quizzed recently by CBI in connection with Saradha scam, commits suicide","a":65},{"b":"d","i":"857248","t":"Former Assam police chief, quizzed in Saradha scam, commits suicide","a":66},{"b":"d","i":"857253","t":"I feared for my life: Jadavpur University Vice-Chancellor","a":67},{"b":"d","i":"857256","t":"Mitchell Johnson to miss start of CLT20, doubtful for rest of tourney","a":68},{"b":"e","i":"502282","t":"Celebrity birthdays: Catherine Tyldesley turns 31","a":69},{"b":"d","i":"857216","t":"Promontory Financial Group Opens Beijing Office","a":70},{"b":"d","i":"857159","t":"As Xi Jinping Visits India, A Flag Meeting to Resolve Border Face-Off","a":71},{"b":"d","i":"857170","t":"Chinese President Xi Jinping wishes Narendra Modi on his birthday","a":72},{"b":"d","i":"857130","t":"CDN startup Fastly raises $40m","a":73},{"b":"d","i":"857117","t":"Narendra Modi to welcome Xi Jinping in Ahmedabad; trade, investment top agenda","a":74},{"b":"c","i":"1814035","t":"Baht Maintains Gain as Central Bank Holds Rate Before Fed Meets","a":75},{"b":"d","i":"857053","t":"Eisai to Present Latest Clinical Data on Halaven(R) (Eribulin) and Lenvatinib at 39th ESMO Congress","a":76},{"b":"d","i":"857055","t":"Hitachi India Developed a Technology to Extract Precisely Designated Information from Electronic Medical Records","a":77},{"b":"f","i":"1068790","t":"Your Top Plays for Today","a":78},{"b":"e","i":"502247","t":"Personal Branding Basics: 3 Easy Steps To Advancing Your Career","a":79},{"b":"f","i":"1068816","t":"Canada slaps fresh sanctions on Russia","a":80},{"b":"c","i":"1813968","t":"Obama: Boots on the Ground for Ebola, Sends Military Forces to West Africa","a":81},{"b":"c","i":"1813931","t":"UPI Almanac for Wednesday, Sept. 17, 2014","a":82},{"b":"f","i":"1068736","t":"Your Top Plays for Today","a":83},{"b":"c","i":"1813898","t":"Thousands flee Philippines volcano","a":84},{"b":"c","i":"1813882","t":"Amazon Has Turned On Carrier Billing For Apps, First In Germany With O2","a":85},{"b":"c","i":"1813874","t":"Mayon volcano spewing lava forces hurried Philippines evacuations","a":86},{"b":"c","i":"1813879","t":"Oi to Sell Africatel Stake Amid Investor Disagreement","a":87},{"b":"c","i":"1813859","t":"As of today, 'cyberspace' is more than just a clever word","a":88},{"b":"e","i":"502224","t":"California King fire Google Earth flyover","a":89},{"b":"e","i":"502225","t":"Today in History for September 17th","a":90},{"b":"e","i":"502229","t":"Anheuser-Busch Publicly Rebukes The NFL Over 'Recent Incidents'","a":91},{"b":"c","i":"1813808","t":"N.J. legislature tackles addiction: List of bills included in major package","a":92},{"b":"c","i":"1813801","t":"Sweeping package of bills to combat heroin, pill crisis set for introduction today","a":93},{"b":"c","i":"1813788","t":"Eyes on Arlington: Good reads at the Friends of the Arlington Public Library Book Sale","a":94},{"b":"g","i":"23037","t":"Xeye, a new concept of micro mode cameras that supports all your devices invites crowdsourcing for its first phase of production on Indiegogo","a":95},{"b":"g","i":"23036","t":"Kingsbuying Announces Best Video Games Gadgets at Competitive Prices","a":96},{"b":"e","i":"502181","t":"Roku Passes 10 Million Mark As Streaming Competition Heats Up","a":97},{"b":"c","i":"1813643","t":"Audi gets permit to test self-driving cars in California","a":98},{"b":"f","i":"1068462","t":"Vikings Lead NFL In Number Of Arrests","a":99},{"b":"f","i":"1068487","t":"Roy Morgan Poll September 17","a":100}]

      100

      Bruker Introduces New Products for Preclinical Imaging at WMIC 2014 - Yahoo Finance UK